Subject: "RE: Is it still murder if the person has been dead for 10000 years?" This topic is locked.
Previous topic | Next topic
Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend CF Website
Top General Discussions The Battlefield Topic #131638
Show all folders

MurphyWed 05-Jul-17 09:59 AM
Member since 30th Dec 2010
1639 posts
Click to send private message to this author Click to view this author's profile Click to add this author to your buddy list
#131688, "RE: Is it still murder if the person has been dead for 10000 years?"


          

Yes it is.

What you're doing isn't digging up some 10000-year old bones and then crunch them in a bonegrinder. You go back to a time where they were still alive, and you kill them.

You cut their life short at whatever age they were at that time, whereas otherwise they may have lived to 250 or however much the dwarves life expectancy is.

The past is not a dream-like world and it's not ghosts or virtual dwarves. Those are just as real as your character's contemporaries.

Hell, there was a dwarf PC who was born in the past. Does it mean it would be okay to murder him, too?

Saying that killing people in the past areas doesn't have an effect in the present is a poor excuse. If I kill that paladin mob with the nodrop weapon that I can't request, he reappears in 3 minutes, but does that mean it's not murder, IC?

  

Alert | IP Printer Friendly copy

HOT Locked Topic(DELETED) [HERALD] Ghrimmli Firebeard the Dwarf-King Sl... [View all] , Death_Angel, Wed 05-Jul-17 02:09 PM
Reply Kinslayer!, Ishuli, 04-Jul-17 10:39 AM, #1
     Reply Thanks, Kstatida, 04-Jul-17 11:27 AM, #2
     Reply Thus, when Ghrimmli jumped beyond fifty kin-kills, it s..., The-me, 04-Jul-17 12:12 PM, #3
     Reply "Unannounced", Rahsael, 04-Jul-17 01:08 PM, #5
     Reply UNANNOUNCED, Ghrimmli (Anonymous), 04-Jul-17 01:48 PM, #6
     Reply Lol. I would say never change...but you never do :) NT, TMNS, 04-Jul-17 02:52 PM, #8
     Reply Even I am not this power gamey. n/t, Lhydia, 04-Jul-17 08:33 PM, #12
     Reply RE: Even I am not this power gamey. n/t, The-me, 04-Jul-17 08:43 PM, #13
          Reply RE: Even I am not this power gamey. n/t, sleepy, 04-Jul-17 09:47 PM, #14
          Reply Are you Lhydia as well?, The-me, 04-Jul-17 10:42 PM, #15
               Reply I meant that it was in my opinion power gamey., sleepy, 05-Jul-17 12:18 AM, #16
                    Reply cool, The-me, 05-Jul-17 09:28 AM, #20
          Reply The bit about killing dwarves in the past..., Lhydia, 05-Jul-17 05:53 AM, #18
               Reply Sure, The-me, 05-Jul-17 09:27 AM, #19
                    Reply RE: Is it still murder if the person has been dead for ..., Murphy, 05-Jul-17 09:59 AM #21
                    Reply RE: Is it still murder if the person has been dead for ..., The-me, 05-Jul-17 10:38 AM, #23
                         Reply RE: Is it still murder if the person has been dead for ..., crom, 05-Jul-17 03:56 PM, #35
                         Reply ????, The-me, 05-Jul-17 04:03 PM, #36
                         Reply RE: Is it still murder if the person has been dead for ..., Murphy, 05-Jul-17 04:29 PM, #37
                              Reply RE: Is it still murder if the person has been dead for ..., The-me, 05-Jul-17 04:34 PM, #38
                    Reply Swing and a miss., Lhydia, 05-Jul-17 10:29 AM, #22
                         Reply RE: Swing and a miss., The-me, 05-Jul-17 10:42 AM, #24
                              Reply guildmaster rewards exp, not imms, Dallevian, 05-Jul-17 02:32 PM, #27
                                   Reply Sorry let me clarify, The-me, 05-Jul-17 02:49 PM, #28
     Reply Well, if it's RP we're talking about, Kstatida, 05-Jul-17 05:53 AM, #17
     Reply RE: Well, if it's RP we're talking about, The-me, 05-Jul-17 10:43 AM, #25
     Reply Whatchu talkin' bout Willis?, Venara, 05-Jul-17 12:56 PM, #26
          Reply RE: Whatchu talkin' bout Willis?, The-me, 05-Jul-17 02:54 PM, #29
               Reply Neat, Venara, 05-Jul-17 03:15 PM, #30
                    Reply Right? n/t, Lhydia, 05-Jul-17 03:17 PM, #31
                    Reply Cool, The-me, 05-Jul-17 03:33 PM, #32
                         Reply So you still don't get it. Gotcha. n/t, Lhydia, 05-Jul-17 03:41 PM, #33
                              Reply No I really dont, The-me, 05-Jul-17 03:53 PM, #34
     Reply Grr. I was "Ghrim" and words hurt :(, TMNS, 04-Jul-17 02:51 PM, #7
          Reply RE: Grr. I was , Ghrimmli (Anonymous), 04-Jul-17 03:05 PM, #9
               Reply Pretty sure everyone has known this for decades, laxman, 04-Jul-17 05:53 PM, #10
                    Reply Kinship, Ghrimmli (Anonymous), 04-Jul-17 08:14 PM, #11
     Reply Krilcov? (nt), robdarken_, 06-Jul-17 12:48 AM, #39
          Reply Heh, The-me, 06-Jul-17 08:06 AM, #40
               Reply Okay it all makes sense then. n/t, Lhydia, 06-Jul-17 03:43 PM, #45
     Reply Also if you were Rooting for Kaiden, The-me, 04-Jul-17 12:15 PM, #4
     Reply Kinslayer , Craftedd (Anonymous), 06-Jul-17 09:21 AM, #41
          Reply You mean you're mcbeth?, Kstatida, 06-Jul-17 09:41 AM, #42
          Reply No idea what you are saying., CD, 06-Jul-17 09:53 AM, #43
               Reply I'll cry till you drown, Kstatida, 07-Jul-17 09:00 AM, #60
          Reply Thanks, The-me, 06-Jul-17 10:16 AM, #44
               Reply You had more than one good kill. ..., Ignolmeer, 06-Jul-17 05:21 PM, #46
                    Reply RE: You had more than one good kill. ..., The-me, 06-Jul-17 06:39 PM, #47
                    Reply I'll bite..., Grifter, 06-Jul-17 07:52 PM, #48
                         Reply You forgot #MCFGA. NT, TMNS, 06-Jul-17 08:26 PM, #49
                         Reply I partially agree with this in the regards that..., Blkdrgn, 06-Jul-17 08:48 PM, #50
                         Reply Meh, Destuvius, 06-Jul-17 09:34 PM, #51
                         Reply I dunno like, The-me, 06-Jul-17 09:41 PM, #52
                         Reply Do you realize how ironic it is to tell Ignolmeer that ..., Seriphax, 07-Jul-17 01:03 AM, #53
                              Reply RE: Do you realize how ironic it is to tell Ignolmeer t..., Kstatida, 07-Jul-17 04:04 AM, #54
                              Reply RE:Or maybe..., Ignolmeer, 07-Jul-17 07:45 AM, #56
                                   Reply RE:Or maybe..., The-me, 07-Jul-17 07:54 AM, #57
                                   Reply RE:Or maybe..., Ignolmeer, 07-Jul-17 08:51 AM, #59
                                        Reply RE:Or maybe..., The-me, 07-Jul-17 09:18 AM, #63
                                             Reply RE:Or maybe..., Ignolmeer, 07-Jul-17 09:28 AM, #65
                                                  Reply RE:Or maybe..., The-me, 07-Jul-17 09:40 AM, #67
                                                       Reply RE:Or maybe..., crom, 07-Jul-17 10:29 AM, #70
                                                            Reply Its fascinating, The-me, 07-Jul-17 10:33 AM, #71
                                   Reply Let me put this into language you might understand, The-me, 07-Jul-17 08:13 AM, #58
                                   Reply RE: Let me put this into language you might understand, Ignolmeer, 07-Jul-17 09:17 AM, #62
                                        Reply >Forgive and forget - we're human up here too despite ..., The-me, 07-Jul-17 09:36 AM, #66
                                             Reply Kaiden what?, Ignolmeer, 07-Jul-17 09:55 AM, #68
                                                  Reply RE: Kaiden what?, The-me, 07-Jul-17 10:14 AM, #69
                                                       Reply RE: Kaiden what?, Ignolmeer, 07-Jul-17 11:09 AM, #72
                                                            Reply ????, The-me, 07-Jul-17 11:15 AM, #73
                                                                 Reply You have to take responsibility for your choices. , Ignolmeer, 07-Jul-17 12:28 PM, #74
                                   Reply After it went boom, no choices are fun :), Kstatida, 07-Jul-17 09:05 AM, #61
                                        Reply Subjective but..., Ignolmeer, 07-Jul-17 09:19 AM, #64
                              Reply RE: Do you realize how ironic it is to tell Ignolmeer t..., The-me, 07-Jul-17 06:41 AM, #55
Top General Discussions The Battlefield Topic #131638 Previous topic | Next topic