Subject: "I'll say I'm sorry- really just trying to raise discussion points" Previous topic | Next topic
Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend CF Website
Top General Discussions Gameplay Topic #45483
Show all folders

lasentiaFri 01-Jun-12 07:51 AM
Member since 27th Apr 2010
987 posts
Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this author Click to add this author to your buddy list
#45529, "I'll say I'm sorry- really just trying to raise discussion points"


          

I know you weren't attacking Djetmai, but he is just the example used so it gets stuck with for the sake of discussion.

My intended point was more of this: If you mandate mage kills, murder all types can sort of spawn from that. Jerr killed a bunch of mages as Lohakahn wihtout a doubt, but he also jumped any mage he saw no matter when he saw it and what they were doing by most all accounts, unless he knew he was being watched.

I do think all Battleragers should want to have mage kills and should go after them, within the proper RP bounds is all. If they are a duerg RBW who spends all day attacking fort pallies instead of mages, or getting flagged and than going after every trib who isn't a mage by just egging them on while they are on duty, boot them. But if they are making that genuine effort to follow Battle policy, I'd think it is alright for them to stay even if they are not having great success in mage hunting.

I know my view is probably not as harsh a stance as Battle may have had in the past (before I even played CF), but I think there is more an element of not intervening with the funstick to a degree that has to be considered in the discussion.

  

Alert | IP Printer Friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote

HOT TopicStandards for bersekers in the village. Sorry Djetmai b... [View all] , Abernyte, Wed 30-May-12 03:17 AM
Reply No worries. It's a fair question., Djetmai (Anonymous), 02-Jun-12 02:58 PM, #51
Reply Berserker should be Scions., Scrimbul, 01-Jun-12 08:45 PM, #32
Reply +1 I think berserker should be earned, like maran. nt, Artificial, 01-Jun-12 10:12 PM, #35
Reply Agree. But then again, I've never had a berserker - jus..., Obaznuk, 04-Jun-12 04:28 PM, #94
Reply So..., Hopelessdwarf, 01-Jun-12 10:27 PM, #36
Reply my vision of it, Artificial, 01-Jun-12 10:54 PM, #38
     Reply This, yes., Scrimbul, 02-Jun-12 01:53 AM, #40
          Reply In truth, are there ever more than 3 deadly berserkers ..., lasentia, 04-Jun-12 05:12 PM, #96
Reply Wrong in every way., Graatch, 01-Jun-12 10:32 PM, #37
Reply You bring up a couple of very good points, lurker, 04-Jun-12 10:02 AM, #86
Reply RE: Berserker should be Scions., Malakhi, 01-Jun-12 11:48 PM, #39
     Reply Yeah, see, that's the problem., Scrimbul, 02-Jun-12 02:16 AM, #41
     Reply RE: Yeah, see, that's the problem., Malakhi, 02-Jun-12 07:14 AM, #43
          Reply Using pk stats as indicators of combo strength is reall..., robdarken_, 02-Jun-12 10:26 AM, #44
               Reply Time to play a Lohakahn style rager, Rob. nt, Artificial, 02-Jun-12 10:43 AM, #46
               Reply RE: Using pk stats as indicators of combo strength is r..., Malakhi, 02-Jun-12 11:19 AM, #47
                    Reply RE: Using pk stats as indicators of combo strength is r..., robdarken_, 02-Jun-12 12:10 PM, #48
                         Reply RE: Using pk stats as indicators of combo strength is r..., Malakhi, 02-Jun-12 01:22 PM, #49
                         Reply I have a problem with the standards and investment, Artificial, 02-Jun-12 03:27 PM, #52
                         Reply RE: I have a problem with the standards and investment, Graatch, 02-Jun-12 07:21 PM, #54
                              Reply Yes yes, I know, Artificial, 02-Jun-12 10:18 PM, #55
                              Reply Like I said, play three and you can talk and we'll all ..., Graatch, 02-Jun-12 10:51 PM, #56
                              Reply This. n/t, Homard, 03-Jun-12 01:37 AM, #57
                                   Reply No, this is stupid., robdarken_, 03-Jun-12 09:00 AM, #62
                                        Reply I don't necessarily think it needs to be 3, but... , Homard, 03-Jun-12 09:01 AM, #64
                                        Reply They're not outrageous claims., robdarken_, 03-Jun-12 09:23 AM, #66
                                        Reply A couple of things., Homard, 03-Jun-12 10:24 AM, #71
                                             Reply RE: A couple of things., robdarken_, 03-Jun-12 10:58 AM, #73
                                                  Reply RE: A couple of things., Homard, 03-Jun-12 11:26 AM, #74
                                                  Reply It's really very basic dude., Scrimbul, 03-Jun-12 03:21 PM, #80
                                                  Reply Really.., Tesline, 03-Jun-12 04:07 PM, #81
                                                  Reply Under Scrimbul. nt, Tesline, 03-Jun-12 04:07 PM, #82
                                                  Reply I would like to chime in here..., Puhguly, 03-Jun-12 04:43 PM, #83
                                                  Reply But does easier make it overpowered., Tesline, 04-Jun-12 05:18 AM, #85
                                                  Reply You're using certain assumptions to frame your argument..., TMNS, 04-Jun-12 02:10 PM, #93
                                        Reply Really?, Tsunami, 03-Jun-12 12:07 PM, #75
                                             Reply Then you just, Artificial, 03-Jun-12 12:52 PM, #78
                                        Reply Using Xilia as an example lost me :(, TMNS, 04-Jun-12 02:05 PM, #92
                                             Reply So did Malakhi comparing Dotran to Lirad as if that mad..., robdarken_, 04-Jun-12 04:58 PM, #95
                                                  Reply Lemur v Pincersvirf is squeued heavily towards pincersv..., TMNS, 05-Jun-12 02:21 PM, #97
                                                  Reply RE: So did Malakhi comparing Dotran to Lirad as if that..., Malakhi, 05-Jun-12 03:27 PM, #98
                                                       Reply What is with you and non-sequiturs, robdarken_, 05-Jun-12 10:37 PM, #99
                                                       Reply I agree. You did not say any of that., Malakhi, 06-Jun-12 07:24 PM, #102
                                                       Reply If you would, enlighten me., Batman (Anonymous), 06-Jun-12 05:54 PM, #100
                                                            Reply RE: If you would, enlighten me., Malakhi, 06-Jun-12 07:14 PM, #101
                              Reply Experience vs speculation., Tesline, 03-Jun-12 07:35 AM, #58
                              Reply When have you played a character that kicked ass ever?, robdarken_, 03-Jun-12 08:53 AM, #63
                                   Reply Strong?, Tesline, 03-Jun-12 08:59 AM, #65
                                        Reply RE: Strong?, robdarken_, 03-Jun-12 09:06 AM, #67
                                             Reply Fine then., Tesline, 03-Jun-12 09:08 AM, #68
                                                  Reply I can't even find the name., robdarken_, 03-Jun-12 09:15 AM, #69
                                                  Reply Forid never made it past 29., Tesline, 03-Jun-12 09:21 AM, #70
                                                       Reply re Drawbacks, Quixotic, 03-Jun-12 12:42 PM, #76
                                                       Reply Wouldnt that be people's playstyles fault not villagers..., Tesline, 03-Jun-12 12:48 PM, #77
                                                  Reply Forid was tough. I liked that char. Sorry I made you ..., TMNS, 04-Jun-12 02:03 PM, #91
                              Reply you throw up fallacy references to blind yourself to th..., laxman, 03-Jun-12 02:06 PM, #79
                              Reply RE: I have a problem with the standards and investment, robdarken_, 03-Jun-12 08:47 AM, #61
                         Reply RE: Using pk stats as indicators of combo strength is r..., Daevryn, 03-Jun-12 10:50 AM, #72
                         Reply No matter how sound your reasoning is..., TMNS, 04-Jun-12 02:02 PM, #90
     Reply Don't think that's a fair assessment, with declining pl..., Vortex Magus, 02-Jun-12 06:00 AM, #42
     Reply Beront just got 422 pks. nt, Artificial, 02-Jun-12 10:42 AM, #45
          Reply Beront is OP., DurNominator, 02-Jun-12 02:55 PM, #50
          Reply True, 100 PKs less than Kostyan (517) from 5 years ago., Vortex Magus, 02-Jun-12 05:04 PM, #53
     Reply I thought about this some more, Daevryn, 04-Jun-12 10:22 AM, #87
          Reply This. n/t, Graatch, 04-Jun-12 11:57 AM, #88
          Reply Especially because after you play one..., TMNS, 04-Jun-12 01:58 PM, #89
Reply In addition, I think he did reasonably well considering..., Vortex Magus, 31-May-12 05:09 PM, #12
Reply I haven't 'judged' him you wanker!, Abernyte, 01-Jun-12 04:23 AM, #14
     Reply I really like you the player, Abernyte., Oldril, 01-Jun-12 07:31 PM, #28
Reply RE: Standards for bersekers in the village. Sorry Djetm..., Malakhi, 31-May-12 09:52 AM, #10
Reply you make me sad, laxman, 31-May-12 04:16 PM, #11
     Reply RE: you make me sad, Malakhi, 31-May-12 08:31 PM, #13
     Reply +1. Dunning-Kruger ftw. nt, Artificial, 01-Jun-12 04:36 AM, #17
          Reply Can you explain how this effect fits in here?, Homard, 01-Jun-12 08:20 AM, #19
               Reply I would have assumed that the bottom third was around 1..., laxman, 01-Jun-12 08:30 AM, #20
               Reply I'm actually kinda shocked as well., Homard, 01-Jun-12 09:20 AM, #21
                    Reply arty may be a victim of the dunning-krueger affect, laxman, 01-Jun-12 10:35 AM, #22
               Reply RE: Can you explain how this effect fits in here?, Artificial, 01-Jun-12 03:02 PM, #25
                    Reply Does not apply in this case., Homard, 01-Jun-12 04:22 PM, #26
                         Reply My originally saying it, Artificial, 01-Jun-12 10:11 PM, #34
     Reply When I was commander..., TMNS, 01-Jun-12 11:08 AM, #23
Reply Followup question to Battle Imms, DurNominator, 31-May-12 03:15 AM, #5
Reply The answer is No, laxman, 31-May-12 06:49 AM, #6
Reply It's sort of silly to think PK skill matters, lasentia, 31-May-12 06:55 AM, #7
Reply RE: It's sort of silly to think PK skill matters, Daevryn, 31-May-12 08:09 AM, #8
     Reply It's just too tough a thing to measure., lasentia, 31-May-12 09:23 AM, #9
     Reply Aargh! I hate this!, Abernyte, 01-Jun-12 04:32 AM, #16
          Reply I'll say I'm sorry- really just trying to raise discuss..., lasentia, 01-Jun-12 07:51 AM #18
     Reply RE: It's sort of silly to think PK skill matters, Iunna, 03-Jun-12 07:59 AM, #59
Reply Can I be clear - I am not complaining about Djetmai!!, Abernyte, 01-Jun-12 04:27 AM, #15
Reply RE: Followup question to Battle Imms, Iunna, 03-Jun-12 08:21 AM, #60
Reply RE: Followup question to Battle Imms, Yean, 03-Jun-12 09:31 PM, #84
Reply You can't use..., Homard, 30-May-12 09:13 AM, #4
Reply Djetmai's PK Statistics, Shaapa (Anonymous), 30-May-12 07:28 AM, #2
Reply One factor..., old_timer, 30-May-12 05:16 AM, #1
     Reply RE: One factor..., Daevryn, 30-May-12 07:31 AM, #3
          Reply Tangent:, Daevryn, 01-Jun-12 02:42 PM, #24
               Reply RE: Tangent:, Oldril, 01-Jun-12 07:28 PM, #27
                    Reply RE: Tangent:, Rayihn, 01-Jun-12 07:45 PM, #29
                    Reply Boo! n/t, Homard (NOT Scrotar), 01-Jun-12 07:56 PM, #30
                         Reply That's hysterical. n/t, Homard, 01-Jun-12 07:57 PM, #31
                    Reply RE: Tangent:, Daevryn, 01-Jun-12 09:28 PM, #33
Top General Discussions Gameplay Topic #45483 Previous topic | Next topic