First, I'm having a lot of fun right now in the game and thats something. Don't listen to them. Just keep doing what you do, Imms. If your changes keep those like beront away, keep doing it.

Just an idea or two about bringing back pk edges. I don't know how to code so I've no idea how difficult these would be.

1. Bring pk edges back once you're character can harm those at hero.
(I'm talking about when your human shapeshifter can harm an elf paladin) this might bring back a lot to get hero pk going again and you'd have a lot of fighting.

2. If you gang someone down then you would get much less. If you are always ganging someone down then maybe none. Imms watch us so you know how good that character is at pk, so maybe base edge points off of that.

3. Risk reward for a dangerous retrieval or taking of an item. Fortress has the empires item and they call in whoever to defend. Paladin follows the one around who's defending and heals them, or a healer follows them and puts sanctuary around the defender. Bard songs on defender. That's more dangerous for the one getting item back, so maybe a bump in PK based edge points.

These are based on what you, the Imms see. Are they always grouped and going after someone? Do they usually pk alone? Are they always asking for the help of others? Just ideas but might help the rolling of new characters that aren't based solely on looking at all things. This would also stop the low level level sitters because they might want edges and not just pks. No edges for pk seems to be the biggest gripe these days.