laxman | Sun 16-Aug-09 08:35 AM |
Member since 18th Aug 2003
1867 posts
| |
|
#26430, "Throwdown vs riddle"
|
I liked that there was the ability to do a lot of stuff solo. I disagree that it was all that reasonable to use brute force in the tower due to the fact that 99% of casters can't cast, communers were so nerfed, and the mobs in there do things that can seriously long term nerf warriors.
I think keeping the overall format and style of the tower would be ideal the difference I would make is the time requirement to pull groups through the riddle parts. For instance if you craft a certain timepiece having it could pull your whole group through things rather then having everyone take the time to make their own. Or if you get a certain thing to protect yourself from a ceertain trap have it extend protection to your group so you don't need to keep leaving and returning to keep collecting said item several times.
maybe make the silent tower only have silence for so long so that people can coordinate or make it somewhat easier or obvious to be able to talk because otherwise people will just do it with AIM open instead. perhaps make it like iunnas shrine with a 24 hour silence or something.
|
|
|
Silent Tower Rethought.... maybe
[View all] , Daevryn, Sat 15-Aug-09 01:42 AM
My Thoughts,
Dragomir,
23-Aug-09 07:46 PM, #90
RE: Silent Tower Rethought.... maybe,
Exit,
21-Aug-09 09:19 PM, #89
RE: Silent Tower Rethought.... maybe,
Tyrjal,
21-Aug-09 02:34 AM, #86
Sadly, the playerbase being what it is, this would like...,
Theerkla,
21-Aug-09 05:27 AM, #87
Oh and..,
Cerunnir,
21-Aug-09 03:49 PM, #88
My take on silent tower.,
Kadsuane,
20-Aug-09 11:09 AM, #84
RE: My take on silent tower.,
Daevryn,
20-Aug-09 11:16 AM, #85
Another possible solution,
incognito,
19-Aug-09 05:11 PM, #83
Make the rewards rot on leaving the tower maybe?,
muchos2,
19-Aug-09 12:06 PM, #81
I like this idea.,
Quixotic,
19-Aug-09 01:47 PM, #82
Modern times,
Valkenar,
18-Aug-09 09:07 AM, #80
Thing is,
incognito,
18-Aug-09 02:42 AM, #79
On time-intensiveness,
DurNominator,
18-Aug-09 12:21 AM, #78
The puzzles are what made it,
Grudan,
17-Aug-09 11:00 AM, #77
RE: Silent Tower Rethought.... maybe,
Xanthrailles,
16-Aug-09 01:58 PM, #73
RE: Silent Tower Rethought.... maybe,
Eskelian,
16-Aug-09 01:57 PM, #72
Crackball thought.,
Quixotic,
16-Aug-09 01:54 PM, #71
Throwdown vs riddle,
laxman,
16-Aug-09 08:35 AM #63
RE: Throwdown vs riddle,
Daevryn,
16-Aug-09 10:04 AM, #65
This sums up the problem with brute force to me,
incognito,
16-Aug-09 12:58 PM, #69
Seriously- Brits don't perma nt,
Abernyte,
16-Aug-09 05:09 PM, #74
RE: Seriously- Brits don't perma nt,
incognito,
17-Aug-09 02:44 AM, #75
people don't post cheats to help,
bobbyp,
16-Aug-09 08:00 AM, #62
For solo, think less puzzle and more complex, intriguin...,
Boon,
15-Aug-09 06:25 PM, #55
my opinion,
Jhyrbian,
15-Aug-09 06:09 PM, #54
RE: my opinion,
A2,
15-Aug-09 09:40 PM, #56
Very good point,
Mekantos,
16-Aug-09 01:09 AM, #58
RE: Very good point,
Daevryn,
16-Aug-09 01:21 AM, #59
did anyone ever figure out how to talk? nt,
Jhyrbian,
16-Aug-09 06:31 AM, #61
Yep.,
Daevryn,
16-Aug-09 10:01 AM, #64
Btw,
Mekantos,
16-Aug-09 12:56 PM, #68
RE: Btw,
Daevryn,
16-Aug-09 01:02 PM, #70
Both Sides of the Coin,
Straklaw,
15-Aug-09 05:12 PM, #52
RE: Both Sides of the Coin,
Daevryn,
15-Aug-09 05:26 PM, #53
RE: Both Sides of the Coin,
Aodh,
16-Aug-09 04:15 AM, #60
Personally I'd like to see,
Lokain,
15-Aug-09 05:08 PM, #51
I think Lokain's idea has merit.,
GinGa,
16-Aug-09 11:43 AM, #66
RE: Silent Tower Rethought.... maybe,
Isildur,
15-Aug-09 03:42 PM, #47
Quick fix,
Mekantos,
15-Aug-09 03:11 PM, #46
That would actually just make it worse,
Nightgaunt_,
15-Aug-09 04:49 PM, #50
RE: Silent Tower Rethought.... maybe,
trewyn,
15-Aug-09 02:43 PM, #44
Two points,
The Heretic,
15-Aug-09 01:42 PM, #38
Idea with this issue:,
GinGa,
16-Aug-09 11:49 AM, #67
That is the worst example you could have picked,
incognito,
17-Aug-09 03:10 AM, #76
RE: Silent Tower Rethought.... maybe,
xander,
15-Aug-09 01:05 PM, #36
RE: Silent Tower Rethought.... maybe,
asylumius,
15-Aug-09 12:25 PM, #33
Long time on-and-offer's thoughts,
RandomThinker,
15-Aug-09 11:49 AM, #24
Thumbs down, imo,
Mort,
15-Aug-09 11:20 AM, #21
An old-timer's viewpoint,
HunterElf,
15-Aug-09 11:21 AM, #20
The biggest thing I think that hurts solo-exploration,
_Magus_,
15-Aug-09 11:41 AM, #23
You are just exploring with the wrong class,
Nightgaunt_,
15-Aug-09 11:57 AM, #27
The problem with that is...,
_Magus_,
15-Aug-09 12:09 PM, #29
RE: The problem with that is...,
Nightgaunt_,
15-Aug-09 12:18 PM, #31
Not to get off on a tangent...,
_Magus_,
15-Aug-09 02:29 PM, #42
RE: Silent Tower Rethought.... maybe,
ORB,
15-Aug-09 10:42 AM, #16
Not a bad idea really! IMM-quest to be able to enter th...,
Amberion,
15-Aug-09 11:38 AM, #22
I don't like Imm quest idea...,
ORB,
15-Aug-09 12:42 PM, #35
I don't like it either...,
Zulghinlour,
15-Aug-09 03:04 PM, #45
RE: Secrecy,
Splntrd,
15-Aug-09 10:42 AM, #15
Good post n/t,
Lokain,
15-Aug-09 12:27 PM, #34
RE: Secrecy,
Zulghinlour,
15-Aug-09 01:29 PM, #37
Precisely...,
asylumius,
15-Aug-09 02:12 PM, #40
I'm dying with curiosity now nt,
Lokain,
15-Aug-09 02:43 PM, #43
I totally agree with you on almost everything...,
TMNS,
15-Aug-09 02:26 PM, #41
RE: Secrecy,
asylumius,
15-Aug-09 02:08 PM, #39
RE: Silent Tower Rethought.... maybe,
Rade,
15-Aug-09 10:37 AM, #14
RE: Silent Tower Rethought.... maybe,
Daevryn,
15-Aug-09 10:51 AM, #17
RE: Silent Tower Rethought.... maybe,
Splntrd,
15-Aug-09 11:02 AM, #19
RE: Silent Tower Rethought.... maybe,
Daevryn,
15-Aug-09 04:13 PM, #49
RE: Silent Tower Rethought.... maybe,
Nightgaunt_,
15-Aug-09 11:56 AM, #26
Nah.,
Splntrd,
15-Aug-09 12:08 PM, #28
RE: Nah.,
Nightgaunt_,
15-Aug-09 12:16 PM, #30
Oh, I see what you're getting at. nt,
Splntrd,
15-Aug-09 12:19 PM, #32
RE: Silent Tower Rethought.... maybe,
Daevryn,
15-Aug-09 04:04 PM, #48
RE: Silent Tower Rethought.... maybe,
Rade,
15-Aug-09 11:55 PM, #57
Meh.,
Iunna,
15-Aug-09 08:44 AM, #12
RE: Silent Tower Rethought.... maybe,
_Magus_,
15-Aug-09 08:22 AM, #11
Does that add anything to the game?,
Stunna,
15-Aug-09 07:02 AM, #10
I prefer the puzzle type area,
incognito,
15-Aug-09 06:44 AM, #9
Why that won't work,
Nightgaunt_,
15-Aug-09 11:53 AM, #25
I almost got into ST...,
Aodh,
15-Aug-09 05:57 AM, #7
Why I'm against groups,
vargal,
15-Aug-09 06:06 AM, #8
RE: I almost got into ST...,
Cerunnir,
15-Aug-09 10:25 AM, #13
Think you know my idea on this...,
Torak,
15-Aug-09 04:34 AM, #6
I really like the idea here!,
Amberion,
15-Aug-09 10:56 AM, #18
My thoughts on this, fwiw,
Mekantos,
15-Aug-09 04:27 AM, #5
No matter what it needs to come back.,
Guilo,
15-Aug-09 03:30 AM, #4
RE: Silent Tower Rethought.... maybe,
vargal,
15-Aug-09 02:32 AM, #3
I wouldn't be against a Silent Reimagining.,
TMNS,
15-Aug-09 02:20 AM, #1
RE: I wouldn't be against a Silent Reimagining.,
Nightgaunt_,
15-Aug-09 02:31 AM, #2
| |
|