Subject: "Great post, and a response." Previous topic | Next topic
Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend CF Website
Top General Discussions Gameplay Topic #4555
Show all folders

ShadowmasterMon 17-May-04 12:34 PM
Member since 18th Mar 2003
329 posts
Click to send private message to this author Click to add this author to your buddy list
#4561, "Great post, and a response."


          

"Nowhere in my post do I urge players to like everything. I value feedback, and a lot of the points you mention (like the changes to multiple Sleep attempts) were things I added as responses to well-thought out posts by players. My specific point is that people should evaluate changes only after they have taken the time to understand their effects, instead of going berserk any time we touch anything significant."

This is gold, here. A lot of players, myself included, have at times forgotten the cardinal rule of constructive criticism. If you are going to bitch about something, for the love of god offer a reason why you think something is wrong (overpowered) and offer possible alternatives so it doesn't amount to a baseless flame thread.

Examples:

1. Scion is overpowered they sux0r.

2. I think the new scion powers are a bit strong because despoil is able to be carried over logins. I.e. I despoil a large item right before I log off, and if I log back in without my item despoil is still up for the timer. I'd like to see this effect dropped if they log in without the item.

Which post do you think the staff is more likely to respond to. Example 1 is a baseless flame. Example 2 is an attempt at constructive criticism. Great post by the way, and I notice change fearers aren't complaining about the recent boost to wand charges

  

Alert | IP Printer Friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote

HOT TopicPontification: Change Fearers [View all] , Valguarnera, Mon 07-Jun-04 08:56 PM
Reply RE: Pontification: Change Fearers, Xaannix, 17-Jun-04 07:10 PM, #35
Reply Change is not the problem., Xaannix, 17-Jun-04 07:00 PM, #34
Reply I have pehaps a unique view on this, Abthalok, 08-Jun-04 10:55 AM, #30
Reply RE: Pontification: Change Fearers, Nightgaunt_, 17-May-04 02:12 PM, #19
Reply About Outlanders (since you mentioned them), Jarvino, 17-May-04 06:39 PM, #6
Reply Outlanders, Zanya, 18-May-04 04:54 PM, #12
Reply Response., Lyristeon, 09-Jun-04 10:22 AM, #32
Reply woot! Flame on!!, Chalupah, 07-Jun-04 08:22 PM, #18
Reply RE: woot! Flame on!!, Zulghinlour, 07-Jun-04 09:05 PM, #22
Reply RE: woot! Flame on!!, Chalupah, 07-Jun-04 09:48 PM, #23
     Reply RE: woot! Flame on!!, Zulghinlour, 07-Jun-04 10:16 PM, #24
          Reply RE: woot! Flame on!!, Chalupah, 07-Jun-04 11:12 PM, #25
               Reply RE: woot! Flame on!!, Zulghinlour, 07-Jun-04 11:21 PM, #26
                    Reply I'm not trying to be difficult, I swear., Chalupah, 08-Jun-04 12:31 AM, #27
                         Reply RE: I'm not trying to be difficult, I swear., Zulghinlour, 08-Jun-04 12:57 AM, #28
                              Reply Two points for using onus in a sentence and not soundin..., Shadowmaster, 08-Jun-04 08:08 AM, #29
Reply RE: woot! Flame on!!, Valguarnera, 09-Jun-04 09:09 AM, #31
Reply Just a few thoughts., Lyristeon, 09-Jun-04 10:43 AM, #33
Reply Good post (small text), Soren, 28-May-04 01:30 PM, #17
Reply RE: Pontification: Change Fearers, Evil Genius (Anonymous), 18-May-04 05:24 PM, #14
Reply Didn't read your post, but "Trust" sums it up., Evil Genius (Anonymous), 18-May-04 05:09 PM, #13
Reply RE: Pontification: Change Fearers, Romanul, 17-May-04 11:31 PM, #7
Reply Assassins, nepenthe, 18-May-04 12:00 AM, #8
     Reply RE: Assassins, Romanul, 18-May-04 04:57 AM, #10
Reply Orb Ramblings, ORB, 17-May-04 12:48 PM, #5
Reply Change Fearing vrs Constructive Critiscism, General_Malaise, 17-May-04 10:43 AM, #1
     Reply RE: Change Fearing vrs Constructive Critiscism, incognito, 17-May-04 11:31 AM, #2
     Reply Regarding Scion:, Valguarnera, 17-May-04 11:51 AM, #3
     Reply RE: Regarding Scion:, Evil Genius (Anonymous), 18-May-04 05:30 PM, #15
     Reply Regarding Criticism:, Valguarnera, 17-May-04 12:11 PM, #20
          Reply Great post, and a response., Shadowmaster, 17-May-04 12:34 PM #4
          Reply regarding flee/sleep, incognito, 18-May-04 03:23 AM, #9
               Reply regarding enhanced reactions, incognito, 18-May-04 07:01 AM, #11
                    Reply Come on, (NOT Graatch), 18-May-04 05:24 PM, #21
                         Reply RE: Come on, incognito, 18-May-04 06:29 PM, #16
Top General Discussions Gameplay Topic #4555 Previous topic | Next topic