Subject: "I don't like this at all. Three reasons..." Previous topic | Next topic
Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend CF Website
Top General Discussions Gameplay Topic #19466
Show all folders

NightshadeTue 09-Oct-07 12:22 PM
Member since 30th Apr 2005
125 posts
Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this author Click to view this author's profile Click to add this author to your buddy list Click to send message via AOL IM
#19467, "I don't like this at all. Three reasons..."


          

While I think the concept of sliding scale damage reduction is a neat idea, I think this would be a poor way to implement it, because:

1) The way your propose to do it would just make mages spam ABS like spells until they improved. This is both boring and lame.

2) In order to spam these spells, they have to find the wand first. This can be time consuming in itself sometimes as a young mage. Once they have it, they'll hoard it for hours and hours and hours until it is spammed to max damage reduction, keeping it out of the hands of those who would actually USE it. Sleeks are a different story, of course, but this is still lame.

3) You can bet your ass you'd see mages using ABS constantly in this case whether they needed it or not for every fight as long as they had it available. More wand hoarding, more time spent gathering wands, and I think fighting classes would generally suffer due to this rather than benefit.

I've given this some thought for various reasons in the past, and I haven't been able to come up with a good solution. Sliding scale damage reduction based on level isn't really a good idea either... I'm at a loss.

--Nightshade

  

Alert | IP Printer Friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote

HOT TopicIdea: Aura, Shield and Barrier [View all] , _Magus_, Tue 09-Oct-07 10:58 AM
Reply Don't implement this, please, Dervish, 11-Oct-07 11:32 AM, #23
Reply They can add this and avoid the Spam (IMHO), Dhargor, 10-Oct-07 04:21 AM, #15
Reply Ignore that post. Somebody already pushed that idea n/t, Dhargor, 10-Oct-07 04:27 AM, #16
Reply Can I make a suggestion?, AnimalFarm, 09-Oct-07 03:26 PM, #9
Reply RE: Can I make a suggestion?, Zulghinlour, 10-Oct-07 02:02 AM, #14
     Reply Think about this..., AnimalFarm, 10-Oct-07 10:37 AM, #17
          Reply Its not the conspiracy nuts.., vargal, 10-Oct-07 11:49 PM, #18
Reply RE: Idea: Aura, Shield and Barrier, Zulghinlour, 09-Oct-07 03:18 PM, #8
Reply See above! n/t, AnimalFarm, 09-Oct-07 03:27 PM, #10
Reply RE: Idea: Aura, Shield and Barrier, Daevryn, 09-Oct-07 12:44 PM, #2
Reply RE: Idea: Aura, Shield and Barrier, _Magus_, 09-Oct-07 01:05 PM, #4
Reply RE: Idea: Aura, Shield and Barrier, _Magus_, 09-Oct-07 01:11 PM, #5
Reply I say ditch practice, Valkenar, 09-Oct-07 01:24 PM, #6
Reply You are not one to txt, Larcat, 10-Oct-07 11:52 PM, #19
     Reply RE: You are not one to txt, Daevryn, 11-Oct-07 07:45 AM, #20
     Reply Additionally:, Daevryn, 11-Oct-07 07:51 AM, #21
          Reply Fair enough! nt, Larcat, 11-Oct-07 08:46 AM, #22
Reply I don't like this at all. Three reasons..., Nightshade, 09-Oct-07 12:22 PM #1
     Reply RE: I don't like this at all. Three reasons..., _Magus_, 09-Oct-07 12:54 PM, #3
          Reply RE: I don't like this at all. Three reasons..., Daevryn, 09-Oct-07 02:20 PM, #7
               Reply RE: I don't like this at all. Three reasons..., _Magus_, 09-Oct-07 05:34 PM, #11
                    Reply I dont think he is missing the point, CrftedDeception, 09-Oct-07 05:47 PM, #12
                    Reply RE: I don't like this at all. Three reasons..., Daevryn, 09-Oct-07 07:01 PM, #13
Top General Discussions Gameplay Topic #19466 Previous topic | Next topic