Yes, I interacted with Karithia quite a bit with various Warlocks and Marans and it was always a distinct displeasure. You may have had some secret "coolness" that was never evident to me but that's sort of moot isn't it? To everyone outside the cadre of people you RP'd that aspect of your role with you were pretty much just an RP griefer.

I don't think all goodies should fit into one mold but I also don't like characters who are intentionally frustrating to deal with as a goodie ally. Just because you RP'd with a handful of people doesn't make it any less frustrating for everyone else. In fact, the elitism aspect of it just reinforces my opinion.

Edit: Addition

And in this particular case its the same thing. The only difference is instead of it being "edgy", the imms considered it "two-faced". Its a fine line I suppose and one that in its best case only appeals to a select few individuals while being frustrating for everyone else.