Gold changes had some positive effects. I can buy a nice piece of gear or a wand from a PC. Before gold couldn't buy anything from a PC because the PC had more than they needed. This means that even a newb can get nice gear or the time of a player to help with something.

Also, if edge points didn't swing things, why is anyone bothered? In most cases it is because they do swing things.

Personally I think the only way to improve on what we had was to give nothing for role writing and to give stuff for rp, but where the rp checker gets views of random players rather than ones they choose to watch.

I do not think pk should matter more for edges (proportionately) as those pk'ing a lot shouldn't be given lots more advantage for it. They already dominate. I expect to break 200 pks and I don't think it should be made progressively easier just because I've already pk'd a lot.

I'd like to see some edges for effort, frankly, and commitment to cabal ideals, class ideals etc.