Now that it comes to it, I'm not really in favor of modifying the weapons but that's they way things are. Let's face it, if you bring a slingshot to a gunfight, you SHOULD be at a pretty severe disadvantage.

So let's ask, what prevents someone that is decked from owning the lowbie ranks. First off, the odds of getting that gear aren't great, sure it happens, but not everyday. Then, there is distention - they can only mop up the lowbie ranks for so long. Then, there is the problem of keeping that gear, trust me it really isn't as easy as you would think. You'd be surprised how often someone can be taken down if you catch them at the right moment or bring a big enough gang. Based on what you have said and the log, I think you went up against the classic mismatch of all times - moderately geared assassin vs. well geared duergar axe spec (hasted to boot). Even if he hit for MUTILATES and EVISCERATES (very-very normal at that level) instead of DISMEMBERS you stood the proverbial snowball's chance in hell of winning a straight up fight.