While I don't exactly agree with the specific ideas you
mentioned, I do think those suggestions are in the direction of
what the CF cabals really need. However...

The first thing I want to do is point out some key issues of
bullsh-t, this goes for Waigerits, other consistent evil players
like myself, or any person who has complained about the Scion
cabal compared to Empire. The general CF player gives a damn
about RP-ing. The ones that do like it become isolated players
in other cabals such as Sylvans, Warlock, or the Herald. Most
players however want a to have their character get a certain
feeling via the powers they have. Players, like myself, like
tangible effects which reinforces their persona. Empire had
Centurions. I liked Centurions. I felt like an Imperial setting
roadblocks. They were neat, they were different, they actually
felt like something lawful and evil. Same goes for old master
brew and tesseract. Both were useful. Shadow's shadowgate made
my old char feel like a shadow. Hell, speaking of powers, the
tattoo power I got from Vilhazarog when I played Ktavialt was
very RP-correct and useful in its own way, and the way I had
to constantly acquire that power was cool in and of itself. That
hooked me in real good, even made my char more cocky and
arrogant, sort of evil quality. Judging by the way Dariana
described her power from Uller, though I do not know what it
is still, I'm sure that enhanced her belief in the RP quality of
Uller's religion more than most immteraction ever would. And
in contrast, especially for warriors, Scion powers aren't really
extravagent and thats what the players are really complaining
about, despite their claim that its an RP deal.

Though I know nobody will listen to me, knowing that I'd hate
to be told what to do as an IMM or Player, I'm still gonna
give my feedback just to amuse myself.

Players: Don't ##### yourself and say you want better RP. I
know I could miniquest and miniquest my heart out and still be
bored. It just so happened I had never had an assassin and
assassinate is neato, plus having a PK range thats 95% against
you makes it a neat challenge so I stayed.

Immortals: Players are gonna bitch and bitch and bitch about the
RP quality of Scion until you give them neat, different powers
that go with the RP of the cabal. Maran and Warlocks are aimless
as well, its just that they have neat powers (for all classes
that join them, I mean). On the other hand, most of you would do
the same if you were mortals on it too. I know its not your way
to respond to these 'put this power in' posts but we're all
annoying whiny brats when we dont get what we want so you might
wanna do it just to make us shut up.