If I do, it's only because you of all people should know what I'm talking about, whether you agree or not, rather than brushing it off so that you don't have to go so far as to imply I'm nuts.

24 dex, a shield and Resist shouldn't be buying him essentially a get-out-of-jail free card from haste + wilderness fam just because I don't know flail. The only reason he died (on multiple occasions even without haste) despite tanking me so well was because his evade didn't fire like even I expected it to. That's it. Normal melee + damage output from Bearcharge.

There've been people saying in both private and public forums that flail, and Parry in general, has been jacked up for ages. I just now on this char noticed spear hits more often than 2 axes even against people who know it just fighting Ugruks. Which, coincidentally, is why I've been using it in PK in lieu of dual wield to comparable or great effect.

I noticed the log above I was wielding a staff which would explain why I didn't hit him as often as I thought I should and why he was dodging and parrying it so well because staff is a bit easy to dodge, but it was still a little ridiculous. I posted the log in question elsewhere and would not be reticent to move it here if asked.