This was both of your faults. I watched what happened. You decided to give the answer you gave. Flagging you and then you camoing was their proof. At that point, they should have removed it. But, flagging you was not in the wrong. Not removing it was in the wrong.

That being said, the iffy points of this character were definitely going to prevent them from the Justiciar position. But, they weren't bad enough to prevent them from the Provincial position, although, that kind of happened because there wasn't someone better for it it as well.

I think this player is still a few heroes from playing that standout character. But, I have seen a lot worse. Keep trucking, you will get it.