Subject: "RE: Ugh...I don't know why, but..." Previous topic | Next topic
Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend CF Website
Top General Discussions The Battlefield Topic #58108
Show all folders

elerosse lazy (Guest)Tue 15-May-07 04:30 AM

  
#58236, "RE: Ugh...I don't know why, but..."


          

>Third line from the bottom, the victim knows he is permanently
>aged. It doesn't say he gets older. It states that it rips
>years away from his life. I obviously understand it just
>fine.
>

No I really don't think you do. The question here is over the use of the word "aged". I would suggest reading the dictionary definition sometime. But, to further my argument I provide one, this is a rather normal, conventional, definition of the word aged.

"The length of time during which a being or thing has existed; length of life or existence to the time spoken of or referred to."*

Now, you don't want us to think of wither as moving someone forward in time, i.e. aging them or in fact having anything to do with time at all. The way you look at it, wither reduces the potential length of the victims life, that is not being aged. The victim ultimately remains the same age they just die early.


>From the helpfile.
>Level(0) WITHER
>Syntax: commune wither <victim>
>
>This horrific malediction attempts to wither the target,
>causing
>extreme strength loss. There is also a chance of the victim
>being permanently aged several years if this supplication is
>successful.

I would reword the helpfile as it stands it is confusing at the very least.

* Definition is from dictionary.com but was consistent with my desk copy of the oxford english diction, and the merriam-webster online dictionary. Additional entries tended to go into greater precision
in regards to aging, marking ones age, or being "aged" as in old. I could not find a single mention remotely close to something being "aged" but showing no signs of age, or not dealing with a length of time.

  

Alert | IP Printer Friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote

HOT Topic(AGE DEATH) [None] Kubilak Bonechewer the Chieftain of ... [View all] , Death_Angel, Tue 15-May-07 08:14 AM
Reply Chief greets ya wurms, har!, Kubilak (Guest), 11-May-07 02:03 PM, #7
Reply RE: Chief greets ya wurms, har!, Bawgor (Guest), 11-May-07 02:49 PM, #9
Reply My favourite healer, Kubilak (Guest), 13-May-07 08:31 AM, #24
Reply Great char!, Asheela (Guest), 11-May-07 02:52 PM, #10
Reply Ah, ranger, Kubilak (Guest), 13-May-07 08:33 AM, #25
Reply Pen sad Chief die....., Penelope (Guest), 11-May-07 06:06 PM, #13
Reply You can't imagine how hard I wanted it to happen, Kubilak (Guest), 13-May-07 02:02 PM, #28
Reply That's a bummer, man, Nihkorzhebus (Guest), 11-May-07 07:29 PM, #14
Reply Thanks, Kubilak (Guest), 13-May-07 02:03 PM, #29
Reply hehe, Haratzi (Guest), 11-May-07 08:18 PM, #15
Reply Scions, hehe, Kubilak (Guest), 13-May-07 02:07 PM, #30
     Reply You don't have to keep unholy, Daurwyn (Guest), 13-May-07 04:35 PM, #34
Reply Nice job, Thrakburzug, 12-May-07 07:53 AM, #17
Reply Thanks, man, Kubilak (Guest), 13-May-07 02:14 PM, #31
Reply RE: Chief greets ya wurms, har!, Xin (Guest), 13-May-07 12:24 PM, #27
Reply Now when I can see you from both sides, Kubilak (Guest), 13-May-07 02:17 PM, #32
Reply RE: Chief greets ya wurms, har!, Palmer (Guest), 15-May-07 05:43 AM, #48
Reply Good riddance yeh pigface bastid, Gromkonk, 11-May-07 04:18 PM, #49
Reply ARR!, Mcgrok (Guest), 11-May-07 06:34 AM, #2
Reply Hmm, to be honest, that sucked..., Kubilak (Guest), 11-May-07 03:03 AM, #1
     Reply RE: Hmm, to be honest, that sucked..., Zekaris (Guest), 11-May-07 07:16 AM, #3
     Reply RE: Hmm, to be honest, that sucked..., Daevryn, 11-May-07 08:04 AM, #4
          Reply Well, Kubilak (Guest), 11-May-07 08:16 AM, #5
          Reply Wither affect doesn't age you per-se, Theerkla, 12-May-07 08:41 AM, #18
          Reply Maybe score should reflect actual age~, Enbuergo1, 11-May-07 12:38 PM, #6
               Reply RE: Maybe score should reflect actual age~, Lyristeon, 11-May-07 02:25 PM, #8
                    Reply I mean make it say "old" when it makes you old etc., Enbuergo1, 11-May-07 03:05 PM, #11
                         Reply RE: I mean make it say, Lyristeon, 11-May-07 04:01 PM, #12
                              Reply JERRY GARCIA IS NOT DEAD! GODS CAN'T DIE! nt, Vladamir, 12-May-07 06:00 AM, #16
                              Reply RE: I mean make it say, ORB, 12-May-07 10:40 AM, #19
                                   Reply RE: I mean make it say, Lyristeon, 12-May-07 11:37 AM, #20
                                        Reply RE: I mean make it say, Elerosse lazy (Guest), 12-May-07 12:15 PM, #21
                                        Reply The Helpfile, Balrahd. (Guest), 12-May-07 01:36 PM, #22
                                             Reply RE: The Helpfile, Lyristeon, 13-May-07 08:24 AM, #23
                                                  Reply RE: The Helpfile, ORB, 13-May-07 10:49 AM, #26
                                                       Reply My last post on this subject., Lyristeon, 13-May-07 03:41 PM, #33
                                                            Reply then what does it do?, CraftedD (Guest), 13-May-07 05:00 PM, #35
                                                            Reply I don't see why it's hard to understand. It's like smok..., Gromkonk, 13-May-07 05:17 PM, #37
                                                                 Reply Really?, CraftedD (Guest), 13-May-07 07:07 PM, #38
                                                                      Reply Heart attack, Valkenar, 13-May-07 08:25 PM, #39
                                                            Reply RE: My last post on this subject., Elerosse lazy (Guest), 13-May-07 05:12 PM, #36
                                                                 Reply Ugh...I don't know why, but..., Lyristeon, 13-May-07 09:18 PM, #40
                                                                      Reply I think it SUX big time, Random opinion (Guest), 14-May-07 03:16 AM, #41
                                                                      Reply RE: I think it SUX big time, Daevryn, 14-May-07 07:03 AM, #42
                                                                      Reply RE: I think it SUX big time, Valguarnera, 14-May-07 07:51 AM, #43
                                                                           Reply I guess I will need a clarification here, Kubilak (Guest), 14-May-07 08:24 AM, #44
                                                                                Reply RE: I guess I will need a clarification here, Daevryn, 14-May-07 09:45 AM, #45
                                                                      Reply RE: Ugh...I don't know why, but..., elerosse lazy (Guest), 15-May-07 04:30 AM #46
                                                                           Reply Holy Hell, LordSMUG (Guest), 15-May-07 04:55 AM, #47
                                                                           Reply Lollers., Marcus_, 15-May-07 09:00 AM, #50
                                                                                Reply Now that makes sense:, Balrahd. (Guest), 15-May-07 11:43 AM, #51
                                                                                Reply RE: Now that makes sense:, elerosse lazy (Guest), 15-May-07 02:49 PM, #53
                                                                                Reply RE: Lollers., elerosse lazy (Guest), 15-May-07 02:42 PM, #52
Top General Discussions The Battlefield Topic #58108 Previous topic | Next topic