Subject: "RE: We set down rules, and followed them exactly." Previous topic | Next topic
Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend CF Website
Top General Discussions The Battlefield Topic #55775
Show all folders

Hrudgir (Guest)Thu 08-Mar-07 03:09 PM

  
#55910, "RE: We set down rules, and followed them exactly."


          

>The rules were, we weren't to raid at the Watcher.

>What we did do, was stop anyone from going into the Fortress
>to raid. There was like 4-5 of you on, and just Hunsobo.

Tsyda, You, Tumarellon and Hunsobo kill the Tara'Bal, Hunsobo continues to the watcher. Tsyda leaves. You try and quicksand trap a Maran (brilliant by the way) in the room where the Tara'Bal spawns. I flee past, and summon you to the Hall of Fire since you are the weakest of the three people I am facing. I was the only Hero range Fortie on at the time.


>What you did, was tried to define raiding as 'helping someone
>get the orb' - which technically could be 'damn, you killed
>me, now I can't defend, screw you for raiding'.

In this case it meant helping my enemy kill my outer, and then hanging around afterwards, while he raids, trying to kill me, in my own cabal.

>We were using
>it like Tribunals use the law, and sitting exactly on the line
>we were told to sit on. You threw a hissy fit and tried to
>tell everyone 'we had raided you for the orb'. Which isn't
>true, we were just helping in a round-about way.

First, I responded ICly, exactly how my character would have. How is that throwing a hissy fit? Second of all, sitting around in my cabal trying to kill me while the person you just killed my outer with is killing my inner? Yes, thats raiding. You've played Maran, you've played Villagers. Would your Maran and Villagers interpret what you did as anything other than raiding?


>You got to learn that this is the way treaties work. They're
>not a 'hey, lets all get into the spirit of loving each other'
>things. They're set rules within which we're going to fight.
>And no, we didn't break those rules. You just weren't smart
>enough to work around them

I wholeheartedly agree with you. I wanted to declare war on Nexus. It wasn't that I wasn't 'smart enough' to work around them. It is that it would have been abysmal RP on my part to 1) do so, and 2) interpret what was going in any other way. When I play Paladin's they don't go in much for compromise or tying to wiggle through loopholes. Maybe you play your Paladins differently. Would it have been better RP for me to say 'Wow that was clever! Good job!"?

>If you hadn't summoned me inside, I wouldn't have been
>fighting you inside. If you'd fled past us, we wouldn't have
>helped hunsobo fight you. Instead, you seemed to think it'd be
>genius to sit in quicksand, at the maran, and fight three of
>us. In all seriousness, if you can't handle that, fair enough.
>But it was not us raiding for your orb, we were there to fight
>only you. And fought only you.

I come to my cabal. You hit me. I think to myself "Hunsobo, Tumarellon, Nanorab. Take out Nanorab first." You were the weakest of the three, so I wanted to eliminate you first. You helped him kill the outer. Tried to kill me with Tumarellon where the outer spawns while Huns is inside raiding. Are you really this dense? I don't mind it OOC at all. I think you were doing what you thought your character should have. What I *don't* understand, however, is why Enarn and I shouldn't have declared war on Nexus except for Immortal intervention.

  

Alert | IP Printer Friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote

HOT TopicDone! Off to dance in far away lands. [View all] , Nanorab (Guest), Mon 05-Mar-07 03:57 PM
Reply RE: Done! Off to dance in far away lands., Verakh (Guest), 14-Mar-07 07:28 PM, #85
Reply The entire Garlic thing was -awesome-, Nano (Guest), 14-Mar-07 08:29 PM, #86
Reply Out of curiosity txt, Hrudgir (Guest), 07-Mar-07 04:51 PM, #60
Reply We set down rules, and followed them exactly., Nano (Guest), 08-Mar-07 01:55 PM, #70
     Reply RE: We set down rules, and followed them exactly., Hrudgir (Guest), 08-Mar-07 03:09 PM #71
          Reply An addenda to this txt, Hrudgir (Guest), 08-Mar-07 03:24 PM, #72
               Reply My essay on Nexus., Nano (Guest), 08-Mar-07 05:08 PM, #74
                    Reply RE: My essay on Nexus., soneone else (Guest), 08-Mar-07 08:16 PM, #75
                    Reply Good comments on the leadership part, Drak (Guest), 09-Mar-07 07:00 AM, #77
                         Reply That area explore and village history txt, Nightwiggler (Guest), 09-Mar-07 12:33 PM, #79
                              Reply Yeah I recently started taking the first steps to compl..., Drak (Guest), 09-Mar-07 12:57 PM, #80
Reply You will be missed as a foe., VhloughVang (Guest), 07-Mar-07 02:52 PM, #58
Reply It's Yhorian. Kaisse/Ritur/Hyzin etc. nt, Aodh, 07-Mar-07 08:11 PM, #63
     Reply Ohhh ####! nt, Taelina (Guest), 07-Mar-07 08:26 PM, #64
Reply I hope all cats goes to heaven, too....., Myrakie (Guest), 07-Mar-07 08:02 AM, #53
Reply Perspectives, I suppose, Alarith (Guest), 07-Mar-07 05:04 AM, #41
Reply I can sympathise completely., Nano (Guest), 07-Mar-07 06:29 AM, #43
Reply Remind me when you delete:, Daevryn, 07-Mar-07 09:15 AM, #55
     Reply Great, now you got me worried (n/t), Alarith (Guest), 07-Mar-07 07:09 PM, #61
          Reply Damn it, I wanna know now!, Nano (Guest), 09-Mar-07 06:24 PM, #81
               Reply Try duergar shaman instead, Alarith (Guest), 09-Mar-07 09:13 PM, #82
Reply And a firedance through the night., Iunna, 06-Mar-07 09:43 PM, #40
Reply I'd be sad, but its barely a good bye, Nano (Guest), 07-Mar-07 06:42 AM, #48
Reply HAR! Aint no lovin like dwarf lovin!, Ysaloerye, 06-Mar-07 01:52 PM, #37
Reply When will the hurting stop?, Nano (Guest), 07-Mar-07 06:37 AM, #47
Reply Other Goodbyes, from Villagers to None!, Nano (Guest), 06-Mar-07 10:28 AM, #20
Reply RE: Other Goodbyes, from Villagers to None!, Edimus (Guest), 06-Mar-07 11:16 AM, #29
Reply Well, Halistanis (Guest), 06-Mar-07 11:25 AM, #31
Reply I oughtta slap you, Tiatan, 06-Mar-07 12:13 PM, #33
Reply Crap! I completely meant to put you in, Nano (Guest), 07-Mar-07 06:36 AM, #46
Reply Nanoguy, Hunsobo (Guest), 06-Mar-07 02:19 PM, #38
Reply He he, Bal'talon actually killed me., Nano (Guest), 07-Mar-07 06:32 AM, #44
Reply RE: Other Goodbyes, from Villagers to None!, Brinkmun (Guest), 06-Mar-07 04:36 PM, #39
Reply Meora and Zaph!, Nano (Guest), 07-Mar-07 06:45 AM, #49
Reply Ugh, Meora (Guest), 07-Mar-07 10:12 AM, #56
Reply RE: Meora and Zaph!, Zaphoedine (Guest), 07-Mar-07 10:10 PM, #66
Reply Phyraxal!, Nano (Guest), 07-Mar-07 07:02 AM, #52
Reply RE: Other Goodbyes, from Villagers to None!, Yean, 07-Mar-07 09:07 AM, #54
Reply I demand logs! Raids were always a great challenge. nt, Nano (Guest), 08-Mar-07 07:11 AM, #67
Reply A big apology first of all, Drakgrak (Guest), 07-Mar-07 11:52 AM, #57
Reply I've already been Commander..., Nano (Guest), 08-Mar-07 07:15 AM, #68
     Reply You were Kaisse? Damn, Drak (Guest), 09-Mar-07 06:55 AM, #76
Reply RE: Other Goodbyes, from Villagers to None!, Kharghurln (Guest), 07-Mar-07 03:03 PM, #59
Reply RE: Other Goodbyes, from Villagers to None!, Karel, 07-Mar-07 08:26 PM, #65
Reply That's pretty strange, Eulinda (Guest), 08-Mar-07 11:45 AM, #69
Reply RE: Other Goodbyes, from Villagers to None!, Ronauk (Guest), 08-Mar-07 04:53 PM, #73
Reply You fuzzy flip-flopper, MENDEcirith (Guest), 11-Mar-07 11:35 PM, #84
Reply Well done...and now Good Luck, Theroc (Guest), 06-Mar-07 09:48 AM, #19
Reply I've always hearted heralds above all others., Nano (Guest), 06-Mar-07 10:57 AM, #24
Reply Too bad, Thos (Guest), 06-Mar-07 02:58 AM, #12
Reply I wonder if she took twitchy or eyes in the back edges...., Nano (Guest), 06-Mar-07 10:57 AM, #25
Reply RE: Done! Off to dance in far away lands., Daevryn, 05-Mar-07 11:36 PM, #9
Reply Actually, Eshval, 05-Mar-07 11:31 PM, #8
Reply An ode to ventriloquate..., Nano (Guest), 06-Mar-07 09:41 AM, #17
Reply Taelina = Tsyda. All you pink ones look alike nt, Nano (Guest), 06-Mar-07 09:42 AM, #18
     Reply RE: Taelina = Tsyda. All you pink ones look alike nt, Tsydaelina (Guest), 06-Mar-07 12:46 PM, #36
Reply Ah, I forget to add!, Nano (Guest), 07-Mar-07 06:51 AM, #50
Reply Well done!, Farigno, 05-Mar-07 10:59 PM, #7
Reply Nexus Goodbyes, Nano (Guest), 05-Mar-07 05:10 PM, #1
     Reply Well, I knew it was coming, Zesam (Guest), 05-Mar-07 06:34 PM, #2
     Reply Hey, its Toodloo!, Nano (Guest), 05-Mar-07 07:34 PM, #3
     Reply And by all means, take the pbf. I have trouble with pay..., Nano (Guest), 05-Mar-07 07:45 PM, #4
     Reply Definately some good times.., Geranim (Guest), 05-Mar-07 07:53 PM, #5
     Reply If no one guessed it, this was Ritur mark 2. :) nt, Yhorian (Guest), 06-Mar-07 10:45 AM, #21
     Reply Dravon and Ebiwen, Nano (Guest), 05-Mar-07 08:19 PM, #6
     Reply Tumarellen!, Nano (Guest), 06-Mar-07 09:38 AM, #16
     Reply Balim!, Nano (Guest), 06-Mar-07 11:04 AM, #28
     Reply RE: Balim!, Balim (Guest), 06-Mar-07 12:23 PM, #35
     Reply RE: Dravon and Ebiwen, Dravon Windgust, 07-Mar-07 07:50 PM, #62
     Reply OOOH!, Biendach (Guest), 06-Mar-07 12:03 AM, #10
     Reply RE: Nexus Goodbyes, Erasifh (Guest), 06-Mar-07 12:58 AM, #11
     Reply The only time I really used pack sense..., Nano (Guest), 06-Mar-07 10:53 AM, #22
          Reply RE: The only time I really used pack sense..., erasifh (Guest), 06-Mar-07 11:45 AM, #32
     Reply Hey, nice of going!, elmeri_, 06-Mar-07 03:07 AM, #13
     Reply Rager bards really are a huge pain, Nano (Guest), 06-Mar-07 10:56 AM, #23
     Reply RE: Nexus Goodbyes, Verakh (Guest), 06-Mar-07 05:04 AM, #14
     Reply No, wording would be the right response!, Nano (Guest), 06-Mar-07 11:00 AM, #26
          Reply RE: No, wording would be the right response!, Verakh (Guest), 06-Mar-07 11:23 AM, #30
     Reply RE: Nexus Goodbyes, Faerdin (Guest), 06-Mar-07 07:08 AM, #15
     Reply I think the invoker bond is awesome now., Nano (Guest), 06-Mar-07 11:02 AM, #27
     Reply FRISKY!!!, Tsyda (Guest), 06-Mar-07 12:15 PM, #34
     Reply GLWTN? Huh? Lost me there! nt, Nano (Guest), 07-Mar-07 06:28 AM, #42
          Reply "Good Luck With the Next" nt, Baerinika, 07-Mar-07 06:34 AM, #45
               Reply Thanks. I guess its obvious if you're smart., Nano (Guest), 07-Mar-07 06:54 AM, #51
     Reply RE: Nexus Goodbyes, VettalAsGuest (Guest), 09-Mar-07 08:56 AM, #78
          Reply You've got style - welcome back! nt, Nano (Guest), 09-Mar-07 11:50 PM, #83
Top General Discussions The Battlefield Topic #55775 Previous topic | Next topic