Jinroh is one of the most skilled warriors I've seen, but it's in a very understated way. He doesn't run around killing everything in sight, but I've seen him take down whole damn parties without too much trouble.

Also no one is disputing whether or not you were a good villager, or even a good berserker. But ANYONE can screw up big time. If Jinroh is accurately describing what happened, then yes that merited uninduction. I wouldn't be surprised if it also made you death marked by Ordasen.

Lastly though. Jemar really liked you, even though you managed to kill him once. I was going to pay you back for that time, but looks like that won't happen now. I thought you were a pretty skilled player, but don't let it go to your head man.