I had no problem with the warder hitting the duergar but I said it is ropey to do this when in a time of war with another cabal, especially one that is not really an ally of the warders as they accept, half-drow and conjurers so are most likely on as good terms as the village is with the warders. The village does not wait by the chasm and imperial palace to jump sylvan mages if they tried for their sapling but I see it as fine to fight them anywhere else. You also will not see a duergar/minotaur/half-drow/drow rager running along to the sylvan grove to kill a mage because they know the empire or the scions or the tribunals or th warlocks raid them. This is the only point I was highlighting.
The village should never, as a general rule, accept any cabals item that they have not participated, actively, in getting. The amount of times paladins would offer me the codex and I would decline until I could go and get it myself, were inumerable. I am not condeming tich's actions unless he took it to attacking more than the duergar and aided the defense of the rift as it is a very fine line to walk. That was all I was saying about it.

Grogim

If it looks like a dwarf, smells like a dwarf and *lick* tastes like a dwarf...then chances are its a dwarf!