From my first characters in justice, to first leader under bria, all through the different forms of the tribunal beforehand, the rule of aiding the criminal was always the same, for those who could deal with criminals outside of the spire.
To note, as far as the laws, the provost has the right to interpret said laws.

To continue in this detail, hitrilipimi had marked me a criminal for aiding a criminal at the tree as bethanny. It was a very accurate mark and warranted. I did not complain, I was a habitual criminal anyway. I did so knowing I would likely be marked.
To dumb it down like this : was what I was doing, directly giving aid to a criminal. Yes it was. Marked earned? Yes it was.

Here is your situation. Provost attacks criminal with guards. You attack the provost, and are legsweeping him, while fighting the criminal. Did you aid the criminal directly, yes. Did criminal even live and get away because of you? Yes. Was warrant earned, yes. What you did though was complain about it, though you knowingly aided a criminal. You ranted and raved you were defending yourself, though you were never attacked. In this, I did not give a false warrant, nor in other situations.

The executioner had asked about maybe 5 or 6 days before umirons note of my warranting of criminals by aiding, and I explained it and why, and told to carry on, and that was the last of it, until umirons note. I do not know if it was umiron that had the executioner at that time or another imm, though from the next oddity makes me feel it was not umiron on a bit of time later.

But believe me kalvin you were not special. The last oooh 20 years of the game being like this makes this nothing new either. Speaking of your own provosts if you truly had them, gave you leeway to both have mercy, and interpret it differently. Does not make it wrong or right, only makes it irrelevant.

Also, you and thelathelao were striking the spire long before I even started retaliating, and hunting non criminal villagers (save one instance with dol). I had been trying to contact umiron and waiting to attack the village or take any steps considering the war that was wanted by said duergar (and you with you being attached to his hip).

For the last bit, no was not warranting everyone that struck at me, only if a criminal was there. I did have one accident where I struck you with guards. You lied your ass off saying no criminal was around, he was ducking in and out of the ruins, but I did forget to release both guards before I attacked you. That was an accident and I apologize for it. But I did warrant people that actively aided criminals (and only gave mercy to those that apologized for it, or were willing to learn from it).
So your last comment is a blatant lie on that one. Also not within the realms, they had to be within the same room. You also lied of the next commont of stripping everyone repeatedly. I used only confiscate unless there was something they had I wanted, or a magistrate had immediate need of, until you and thelath stripped me. You two were the ones that wanted treatment in this fashion, you got what you wanted in return. YOU and thelath were sripped repeatedly. Never stripped anyone else but villagers.

You are pathetic, whiney and a liar. Please dont post on my death thread until you will be honest about the things you have done.