You need to do a little bit more digging than just grepping logs for when a cabal item was given to another cabal member or another member of another cabal.

Orcs, Empire, and Tribunal raided Fortress last week. The Tribunal sat outside with a snare, the orcs and Empire raided, the Empire fled at the last minute, letting the orcs finish.

So yeah, I guess if your very narrow view of things is that they didn't actually give it over, I guess you are right? But I cannot believe that is something you would hold onto.

So then they all go on their merry way and somehow this passes muster?