Subject: "I'm starting to come around to your POV" Previous topic | Next topic
Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend CF Website
Top General Discussions Gameplay Topic #37256
Show all folders

HomardFri 11-Mar-11 04:59 PM
Member since 10th Apr 2010
959 posts
Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this author Click to view this author's profile Click to add this author to your buddy list
#37306, "I'm starting to come around to your POV"


          

>2. a spiritual power or personal quality that gives an individual influence or authority over large numbers of people.

>Never once in that definition does it mention TRUST. It does, however, mention AUTHORITY AND INFLUENCE.

It seems to me that based on this definition that a Drow should be capapble of having tremendous charisma.

I suppose it comes down to a matter of game balance. How much would the game change if Drow CHR was bumped up to 22 or 23? Would a Drow bard be overpowered? I'm inclined to think that the answer is no.

I'm realizing that one funny aspect of this discussion is that the value of charisma as a stat has been an issue since Dungeons and Dragons was in its infancy. I'm trying to remember which AD&D supplement attempted to add the stat of "comeliness" because charisma and physical attractiveness were entertwined, but shouldn't really have been. It may have been "Unearthed Arcana."

I'm pretty sure it just remained in the game because people needed a dump stat. I know when I was a kid that nobody, but nobody, ever actually played a bard.

  

Alert | IP Printer Friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote

TopicWhy can't drow be bards? [View all] , TJHuron, Fri 04-Mar-11 09:12 AM
Reply 16 charisma, lasentia, 05-Mar-11 07:02 PM, #1
     Reply RE: 16 charisma, MoetEtChandon, 05-Mar-11 07:57 PM, #2
     Reply RE: 16 charisma, TJHuron, 06-Mar-11 03:33 PM, #3
          Reply RE: 16 charisma, lasentia, 06-Mar-11 03:44 PM, #4
               Reply I see what you are saying, but, I disagree, TJHuron, 11-Mar-11 10:48 AM, #5
                    Reply I think your analogy is a little off, Homard, 11-Mar-11 01:51 PM, #6
                         Reply RE: I think your analogy is a little off, Artificial, 11-Mar-11 02:11 PM, #7
                         Reply Regardless of the analogy..., TJHuron, 11-Mar-11 02:42 PM, #8
                         Reply I'm starting to come around to your POV, Homard, 11-Mar-11 04:59 PM #10
                              Reply RE: I'm starting to come around to your POV, TJHuron, 11-Mar-11 05:28 PM, #11
                                   Reply My guess:, blackbird, 11-Mar-11 06:35 PM, #12
                                        Reply Maybe, but, that still doesn't have anything to do with..., TJHuron, 11-Mar-11 06:54 PM, #13
                                             Reply RE: Maybe, but, that still doesn't have anything to do ..., blackbird, 12-Mar-11 08:37 AM, #15
                                                  Reply RE: Maybe, but, that still doesn't have anything to do ..., TJHuron, 13-Mar-11 01:36 PM, #19
                         Reply One more thing, TJHuron, 11-Mar-11 04:35 PM, #9
                         Reply I really probably should have gone drow :) NT, Jindicho (Anonymous), 11-Mar-11 09:29 PM, #14
                              Reply Why Jindicho should NOT have gone Drow., Homard, 12-Mar-11 02:38 PM, #16
                                   Reply I was a big fan of him too., lasentia, 12-Mar-11 03:21 PM, #17
                                   Reply You misunderstood..., Jindicho (Anonymous), 12-Mar-11 04:56 PM, #18
Top General Discussions Gameplay Topic #37256 Previous topic | Next topic