Subject: "RE: Religon? Is it dead?" Previous topic | Next topic
Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend CF Website
Top General Discussions Gameplay Topic #336
Show all folders

incognitoTue 11-Mar-03 05:01 AM
Member since 04th Mar 2003
4495 posts
Click to add this author to your buddy list
#358, "RE: Religon? Is it dead?"


          

>I mean honestly, a single assassin being asked to assassinate
>someone else... OOOh, that's a huge "war". First of all, your
>god only told you to kill this person. That's not how religon
>works. Religon works when your god tells the head of the
>religon that you follow, that (so and so) is a blasphemor, and
>should be killed.
>

I PLAYED A SINGLE ASSASSIN. Does that mean I was the only person asked to do this kind of thing? No. Stop making assumptions based on no experience.

In fact, the reason I was asked to kill the Priestess (amongst a number of other people) was completely down to them being anaethma (sp?) to the religion of the God I was serving.

So, in fact, you have just stated this is religion.

>If several people listened, and decided to kill because of the
>edicts of god, then that would be religious.

OK. So which bit of the people who were working for me to do this didn't you understand? That is (A) several people, and (B) killing because of the edicts of that god.

Again, you have just stated that this is religion.

> Religon is
>great, because it allows those with personal avenues to god to
>make decisions, even if those decisions aren't the intention
>of the god.
>

No one is disputing this, though some religions will not give you that flexibility.

>That's called faith.. Faith is believing what your religous
>leader tells you. Are they favored by god? Will you be
>rewarded for following them? Are they following the
>constitution (so to speak) of the religon? Those sorts of
>questions are what faith is all about.
>
>
>I believe in god, but I'm not religious.

This is my last post on this topic. I am kicking myself already for wasting time explaining stuff to someone who is arguing from a position of ignorance, who isn't actually taking in what I am trying to say (which incidentally is almost completely, if not completely, corroborated by one of the immortals).

  

Alert | IP Printer Friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote

TopicReligon? Is it dead? [View all] , josiah (inactive user), Mon 10-Mar-03 03:49 PM
Reply In a way I like the idea but, Nightgaunt_, 11-Mar-03 05:39 AM, #14
Reply RE: In a way I like the idea but, Valguarnera, 11-Mar-03 02:06 PM, #15
Reply I encourage you to keep posting here, not anywhere else..., DwE, 10-Mar-03 07:07 PM, #3
Reply No., Valguarnera, 10-Mar-03 05:37 PM, #2
Reply RE: No., josiah (Anonymous), 10-Mar-03 11:12 PM, #4
     Reply RE: No., Valguarnera, 11-Mar-03 01:35 AM, #6
     Reply .That's not organized religon, though., josiah (Anonymous), 11-Mar-03 01:37 AM, #7
          Reply RE: .That's not organized religion, though., Valguarnera, 11-Mar-03 01:54 AM, #8
          Reply Okay =) Different strokes for different folks. (nt), josiah (Anonymous), 11-Mar-03 02:08 AM, #9
          Reply Stop wasting your time Valg., ORB, 11-Mar-03 02:16 AM, #11
               Reply RE: Stop wasting your time Valg., josiah (Anonymous), 11-Mar-03 02:38 AM, #12
                    Reply RE: Stop wasting your time Valg., Valkenar, 12-Mar-03 01:02 AM, #17
          Reply my dogma just pissed in your rosaries., shokai, 11-Mar-03 02:11 AM, #10
     Reply RE: No., Quislet, 11-Mar-03 06:42 PM, #16
Reply RE: Religon? Is it dead?, incognito, 10-Mar-03 04:30 PM, #1
     Reply RE: Religon? Is it dead?, josiah (Anonymous), 11-Mar-03 12:23 AM, #5
          Reply RE: Religon? Is it dead?, incognito, 11-Mar-03 05:01 AM #13
Top General Discussions Gameplay Topic #336 Previous topic | Next topic