There is no right or wrong way to play the game. People always try to say this or that is "good for the game," but what they really mean is it's good for what they enjoy about the game. Which might not be what you enjoy about the game. Personally, I am always happier to see people making interesting choices that will lead to more variety in interactions. I didn't interact with your character, there was no Nightreaver while I was Sunwarden, but I say good for you for not making the obvious choice. The fact that people are talking about it is a good thing, no matter what their view of that choice was.