One of the thoughts I had was if Wis-invis didn't apply to the who list (the immortal shows up on who, but not where or can't be seen in the same room).

Oh, god no.

1) Just because someone is on, doesn't mean they're available.

I know the arguement against this is people will RP when their imm is about and won't when they aren't, but honestly I'm not 100% sure I agree with that.

2) Speaking from experience, a number of players are very different when they know you're watching, vs. when you quietly peek in without announcing your presence.

There's a ton of smaller reasons. This is nowhere in the realm of possibility.

valguarnera@carrionfields.com