Subject: "RE: Request, let's try again :)" Previous topic | Next topic
Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend CF Website
Top General Discussions Gameplay Topic #27019
Show all folders

DurNominatorSun 04-Oct-09 07:46 AM
Member since 08th Nov 2004
2018 posts
Click to send private message to this author Click to add this author to your buddy list
#27034, "RE: Request, let's try again :)"
Edited on Sun 04-Oct-09 07:47 AM

          

My response is bolded, Dwoggurd's text in reference is not.

>Reasons why "barely scratches" isn't the best for this:
>1) not very accurate description of zero damage. "scratches"
>assumes some damage even it's just "barely". Strictly
>speaking, for zero damage "misses" was better.

In this case, the attack does not miss. It hits, but fails to hurt due to the opponent's damage reduction. It does not make sense that a lash "misses" you, yet lags you for two rounds. If you have problem with "barely scratches" in this sense, maybe replace it with "fails to hurt", which is also a slightly shorter expression as well?

>2) It is not conforming with the single-worded style for
>nearly all other damage verbs (except the unspeak). I don't
>think that breaking this trend was necessary as there are
>other verbs that could describe zero damage better and in a
>single word.

Unspeaks doesn't conform to it either. The fact remains that you haven't yet suggested a better single word alternative for "barely scratches". Your suggestion, "touches", was worse than barely scratches.

>3) Minor issue: highlights needs an update. They would need an
>update anyway, but for a single verb it's more
>regular/easier.

If your highlights are that great, they should be implemented in the game. This is why I think Imms shouldn't care about ####ing over your highlights.

  

Alert | IP Printer Friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote

HOT Topicmisses vs. barely scratches [View all] , Zulghinlour, Sat 03-Oct-09 01:23 PM
Reply Request, let's try again :), Dwoggurd, 04-Oct-09 03:48 AM, #12
Reply RE: Request, let's try again :), DurNominator, 04-Oct-09 07:47 AM #13
     Reply Re, Dwoggurd, 04-Oct-09 08:10 AM, #14
          Reply RE: Re, DurNominator, 04-Oct-09 08:36 AM, #15
               Reply Christmas Tree?, Torak, 05-Oct-09 03:38 PM, #36
                    Reply RE: Christmas Tree?, DurNominator, 05-Oct-09 10:23 PM, #38
                         Reply I agree., Cerunnir, 05-Oct-09 11:28 PM, #39
                              Reply I think you two are idiots, Dwoggurd, 06-Oct-09 02:14 AM, #40
                                   Reply Re: Prompt, Zulghinlour, 06-Oct-09 02:43 AM, #41
                                   Reply Not good solution, Dwoggurd, 06-Oct-09 02:52 AM, #42
                                        Reply RE: Not good solution, Zulghinlour, 06-Oct-09 11:35 AM, #47
                                             Reply Microsoft to the rescue, Mort, 06-Oct-09 12:30 PM, #48
                                             Reply GA implementation in ROM, Dwoggurd, 06-Oct-09 03:12 PM, #49
                                   Reply Coloring, Cerunnir, 06-Oct-09 05:53 AM, #43
                                   Reply Eh, Dwoggurd, 06-Oct-09 06:16 AM, #44
                                        Reply RE: Eh, Cerunnir, 06-Oct-09 07:37 AM, #45
                                   Reply RE: I think you two are idiots, DurNominator, 06-Oct-09 09:35 AM, #46
Reply RE: misses vs. barely scratches, Isildur, 03-Oct-09 05:38 PM, #3
Reply RE: misses vs. barely scratches, Zulghinlour, 03-Oct-09 06:11 PM, #4
     Reply Fear the massively protected armadillo!, Straklaw, 04-Oct-09 08:56 PM, #20
Reply Damn that's a good idea. (n/t), Daevryn, 03-Oct-09 02:07 PM, #1
     Reply Request, Dwoggurd, 03-Oct-09 05:27 PM, #2
          Reply RE: Request, Zulghinlour, 03-Oct-09 06:11 PM, #5
               Reply Uhm... why?, Dwoggurd, 03-Oct-09 08:20 PM, #6
                    Reply RE: Uhm... why?, Mort, 03-Oct-09 08:48 PM, #7
                    Reply I knew, Dwoggurd, 03-Oct-09 08:54 PM, #8
                         Reply You can make a separate highlight trigger for barely sc..., DurNominator, 04-Oct-09 02:45 AM, #9
                    Reply RE: Uhm... why?, Zulghinlour, 04-Oct-09 02:58 AM, #10
                         Reply What's funny..., Torak, 04-Oct-09 03:47 AM, #11
                              Reply RE: What's funny..., Zulghinlour, 04-Oct-09 09:50 AM, #16
                              Reply Should check it out, Torak, 04-Oct-09 01:00 PM, #17
                              Reply That actually kinda is., dwimmerling, 04-Oct-09 03:44 PM, #18
                              Reply So the basics are..., Zulghinlour, 04-Oct-09 09:11 PM, #21
                                   Reply If this means.., Cerunnir, 04-Oct-09 09:35 PM, #22
                                        Reply Yup...coming to a crash/reboot near you (n/t), Zulghinlour, 04-Oct-09 09:39 PM, #23
                                             Reply Three suggestions you may or may not like., Cerunnir, 04-Oct-09 09:55 PM, #24
                                                  Reply RE: Three suggestions you may or may not like., Daevryn, 04-Oct-09 10:23 PM, #25
                                                  Reply Well there you go :), Cerunnir, 04-Oct-09 10:29 PM, #27
                                                  Reply RE: Three suggestions you may or may not like., Isildur, 04-Oct-09 10:24 PM, #26
                                                  Reply Me too. nt, Java, 04-Oct-09 10:35 PM, #29
                                                  Reply Red! (n/t), Mort, 05-Oct-09 04:11 AM, #31
                                                       Reply Indeed. (n/t), DurNominator, 05-Oct-09 06:02 AM, #32
                                                            Reply RE: Indeed. (n/t), Isildur, 05-Oct-09 08:44 AM, #33
                                                                 Reply You'll learn to change your imperialist ways, comrade!~, Mort, 05-Oct-09 11:58 AM, #34
                                                                      Reply Play it loud and proud, comrade!, Rodriguez, 05-Oct-09 02:16 PM, #35
                                                                           Reply Here's a version with lyrics in it., DurNominator, 05-Oct-09 03:52 PM, #37
                                                  Reply RE: Three suggestions you may or may not like., Zulghinlour, 04-Oct-09 10:34 PM, #28
                                                       Reply RE: Three suggestions you may or may not like., Cerunnir, 04-Oct-09 10:50 PM, #30
                                                       Reply (PK) is now highlighted in red (n/t), Zulghinlour, 07-Oct-09 11:53 PM, #51
                              Reply His highlights are useful., Zephon, 04-Oct-09 08:48 PM, #19
                              Reply No everyone can use it as it's not for a free client., Asthiss, 07-Oct-09 06:21 AM, #50
Top General Discussions Gameplay Topic #27019 Previous topic | Next topic