Makes sense.

On the other hand, those bards would have no way of knowing you took the anti-Romantic edge unless they get an echo. They might just chalk it up to the RNG that their songs fail to work as often on you as they do on other people.

Additional question:

Could one be simultaneously anti-Romantic, anti-Tragic, anti-Comedic and anti-Epic, or do those four make up a set from which a given character can only choose one?