Subject: "Re: Battle Revamp & replies" Previous topic | Next topic
Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend CF Website
Top General Discussions Gameplay Topic #8027
Show all folders

NNNickThu 31-Mar-05 03:42 AM
Member since 04th Mar 2003
94 posts
Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this author Click to view this author's profile Click to add this author to your buddy list
#8076, "Re: Battle Revamp & replies"


          

I am going to side with Dwoggurd and say it is pretty bad idea.

Incremental resist - I personally like it but I dont see any real purpose of doing this change.

Deathblow - Abernyte and many many other players (including me) think it have to go.
It served it's purpose nuking 2k hp Masters. Now it is incredibly unbalanced.

Some pointers:
1) Battles are all about destroying magi. But deathblow rarely changes the outcome of the fight between villager and mage.
2) It grants tremendous advantage against warrior_type classes who dont have dam_reduction options build into class (aka sanc).
3) Deathblow costs nothing. (Being villager has its drawbacks. But deathblow skill itself does not.)
4) Deathblow begs to be abused. Unscrupulous villager could easily repeately kill everybody in his pk (typically in middle ranks).
5) It forces enemies of Battle to resort to ganging.
6) Substitutes player skill for RND.

These arguments could go on and on.
But here is my proposal:
A) Replace current deathblow with manual_input owaza_type skill.
B) Dump the 'no-ganging' rule for berserkers. It never really worked and is constant point of complaints.

Reason for this - Every other cabal gangs. Some are even encouraged to this type of behavior. Berserkers are not supposed to... in exchange they are given DEATHBLOW.

Screw this. How about Ragers play by the same rules as everybody else?

My $0.02,

-=NNNick=-

  

Alert | IP Printer Friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote

HOT TopicComplete Battle Revamp: My Most Controversial Idea Thus... [View all] , Wilhath, Mon 28-Mar-05 10:32 PM
Reply A last word on this, Khasotholas, 01-Apr-05 09:09 AM, #38
Reply Thanks big guy, Wilhath, 01-Apr-05 09:31 AM, #39
Reply Woot Khasotholas!, Straklaw, 01-Apr-05 11:26 AM, #40
Reply Soooo...., Mekantos, 31-Mar-05 12:08 PM, #31
Reply Stop crying already..., ORB, 31-Mar-05 07:50 AM, #28
Reply Make deathblow more powerful against gangs, Theerkla, 31-Mar-05 11:29 AM, #30
Reply Re: Battle Revamp & replies, NNNick, 31-Mar-05 03:42 AM #27
Reply One point:, nepenthe, 31-Mar-05 08:34 AM, #29
     Reply RE: One point:, NNNick, 31-Mar-05 02:01 PM, #32
          Reply RE: One point:, (NOT Graatch), 31-Mar-05 02:17 PM, #33
          Reply RE: One point:, Evil Genius (Anonymous), 01-Apr-05 07:40 AM, #37
               Reply Small update, NNNick, 01-Apr-05 11:58 AM, #41
Reply How about this Immortals...., NewTrapper, 29-Mar-05 07:50 PM, #22
Reply wow, incognito, 29-Mar-05 08:00 PM, #23
     Reply RE: wow, Valkenar, 30-Mar-05 10:47 AM, #24
          Reply if you read his post, incognito, 30-Mar-05 11:38 AM, #25
Reply RE: Complete Battle Revamp: My Most Controversial Idea ..., Aarn, 29-Mar-05 02:49 PM, #15
Reply RE: Complete Battle Revamp: My Most Controversial Idea ..., Gaenlin, 29-Mar-05 02:22 PM, #13
Reply RE: Complete Battle Revamp: My Most Controversial Idea ..., nepenthe, 29-Mar-05 02:30 PM, #14
Reply RE: The tweaking process., Valguarnera, 29-Mar-05 02:53 PM, #16
Reply rock paper scissors on crack, Tahren, 29-Mar-05 03:00 PM, #17
Reply Duh, Dwoggurd, 29-Mar-05 10:43 AM, #5
Reply Echo, Evil Genius (Anonymous), 29-Mar-05 11:36 AM, #6
Reply Harrumph, Khasotholas, 29-Mar-05 10:16 AM, #4
Reply RE: Harrumph, Tahren, 29-Mar-05 11:59 AM, #7
Reply RE: Harrumph, Evil Genius (Anonymous), 29-Mar-05 12:01 PM, #8
     Reply RE: Harrumph, Tahren, 29-Mar-05 03:17 PM, #18
          Reply RE: Harrumph, Evil Genius (Anonymous), 29-Mar-05 04:03 PM, #19
               Reply I've actually always thought a druid could have a solid..., (NOT Graatch), 29-Mar-05 04:34 PM, #20
               Reply I don't think we disagree here, Tahren, 29-Mar-05 06:16 PM, #21
Reply So how about answer when Morts of battle have questions, Drag0nSt0rm, 29-Mar-05 12:35 PM, #9
     Reply I didn't post this expecting "something to be done", Wilhath, 29-Mar-05 12:48 PM, #10
          Reply Don't kid yourself, Drag0nSt0rm, 29-Mar-05 01:02 PM, #11
               Reply RE: Don't kid yourself, nepenthe, 29-Mar-05 01:56 PM, #12
                    Reply Well, Drag0nSt0rm, 30-Mar-05 12:44 PM, #26
Reply a few things I'd think need addressing, incognito, 29-Mar-05 05:55 AM, #2
Reply RE: a few things I'd think need addressing, Wilhath, 29-Mar-05 08:58 AM, #3
Reply I like the general concept, change is good. n/t, rulanit, 29-Mar-05 04:44 AM, #1
     Reply By the hairs on me stinkin' arse..., HammerSong, 31-Mar-05 02:36 PM, #34
          Reply Hairs aside..., Khasotholas, 31-Mar-05 02:56 PM, #35
               Reply RE: Hairs aside..., HammerSong, 31-Mar-05 03:19 PM, #36
Top General Discussions Gameplay Topic #8027 Previous topic | Next topic