Jarmel | Wed 20-Sep-17 08:58 PM |
Member since 19th Jul 2015
375 posts
| |
|
#68955, "RE: Exactly"
|
See my response to Murphy, you are looking at the example in isolation all 8 points must be taken into account.
Never did I say it "actually happened", it was always intended as an example because I think in such a situation its fair and reasonable to flag some if not all of that group. Regardless of if the group was there first or not.
What my actual intent is ... well the actual outcome that has happened in the last couple of hours ... Yourself (I think you) and Murphy who have strongly argued that this should never happen have actually agreed somewhere there is a reasonable line in the sand.
|
|
|
Trib Law for Murphy
[View all] , Lhydia, Tue 12-Sep-17 05:22 AM
![](./images/mesg_level.gif) Law vs. Man,
Saagkri,
21-Sep-17 05:49 PM, #62
![](./images/middle_mesg_level.gif) ![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) RE: Law vs. Man,
Jarmel,
25-Sep-17 10:48 PM, #70
![](./images/mesg_level.gif) Trib Law and Consequences,
Tac,
21-Sep-17 04:00 PM, #60
![](./images/middle_mesg_level.gif) ![](./images/mesg_level.gif) That's my main issue with creative flagging,
Kstatida,
21-Sep-17 04:08 PM, #61
![](./images/middle_mesg_level.gif) ![](./images/middle_mesg_level.gif) ![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) I think that's universally true. No one argues their m...,
Tac,
22-Sep-17 11:32 AM, #65
![](./images/middle_mesg_level.gif) ![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) RE: Trib Law and Consequences,
Jarmel,
25-Sep-17 10:55 PM, #71
![](./images/mesg_level.gif) Yeah that's what I do,
Murphy,
26-Sep-17 01:09 AM, #72
![](./images/middle_mesg_level.gif) ![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) RE: Yeah that's what I do,
Kstatida,
26-Sep-17 02:26 AM, #73
![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) RE: Trib Law and Consequences,
Tac,
26-Sep-17 10:49 AM, #74
![](./images/mesg_level.gif) Epic fail Murphy,
Lhydia,
21-Sep-17 08:26 AM, #57
![](./images/middle_mesg_level.gif) ![](./images/mesg_level.gif) RE: Epic fail Murphy,
Kstatida,
21-Sep-17 08:59 AM, #58
![](./images/middle_mesg_level.gif) ![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) Good for you. Move along.,
Murphy,
21-Sep-17 09:51 AM, #59
![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) Not everything is free to be reinterpreted,
Murphy,
18-Sep-17 08:18 AM, #1
![](./images/mesg_level.gif) RE: Not everything is free to be reinterpreted,
Jarmel,
18-Sep-17 08:59 AM, #2
![](./images/middle_mesg_level.gif) ![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) You're making no sense, please stay on topic.,
Murphy,
18-Sep-17 09:18 AM, #4
![](./images/mesg_level.gif) Was that before or after he left the game forever? n/t,
Lhydia,
18-Sep-17 09:05 AM, #3
![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) i feel like you know this,
laxman,
18-Sep-17 11:16 PM, #5
![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) Exactly,
Murphy,
19-Sep-17 12:52 AM, #6
![](./images/mesg_level.gif) Any IMM care to weigh in here? (n/t),
Current challenge (Anonymous),
19-Sep-17 02:22 PM, #7
![](./images/middle_mesg_level.gif) ![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) Sure.,
Ishuli ,
20-Sep-17 12:16 PM, #8
![](./images/mesg_level.gif) Do you take into account,
Kstatida,
20-Sep-17 12:58 PM, #9
![](./images/middle_mesg_level.gif) ![](./images/mesg_level.gif) You're assuming,
sleepy,
20-Sep-17 03:50 PM, #10
![](./images/middle_mesg_level.gif) ![](./images/middle_mesg_level.gif) ![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) As someone who was around at the time...,
Lhydia,
20-Sep-17 03:52 PM, #12
![](./images/middle_mesg_level.gif) ![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) RE: As someone who was around at the time...,
sleepy,
20-Sep-17 04:11 PM, #13
![](./images/middle_mesg_level.gif) ![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) I don't think CF's trib laws were written by lawyers,
lasentia,
22-Sep-17 09:22 AM, #64
![](./images/middle_mesg_level.gif) ![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) RE: Do you take into account,
Ishuli ,
20-Sep-17 03:49 PM, #11
![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) Flagging someone who defends their cabal,
Murphy,
20-Sep-17 04:33 PM, #14
![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) RE: Flagging someone who defends their cabal,
Ishuli ,
20-Sep-17 04:43 PM, #15
![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) So being off-duty matters after all?,
Murphy,
20-Sep-17 04:59 PM, #16
![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) RE: So being off-duty matters after all?,
Ishuli ,
20-Sep-17 05:38 PM, #17
![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) RE: So being off-duty matters after all?,
Murphy,
20-Sep-17 08:02 PM, #21
![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) RE: So being off-duty matters after all?,
Ishuli ,
20-Sep-17 08:13 PM, #22
![](./images/mesg_level.gif) What do you mean it doesn't specify jurisdiction?,
Murphy,
20-Sep-17 08:52 PM, #26
![](./images/middle_mesg_level.gif) ![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) RE: What do you mean it doesn't specify jurisdiction?,
Ishuli ,
20-Sep-17 09:20 PM, #39
![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) Holy Molly!,
Kstatida,
21-Sep-17 04:56 AM, #54
![](./images/mesg_level.gif) RE: So being off-duty matters after all?,
sleepy,
20-Sep-17 09:00 PM, #28
![](./images/middle_mesg_level.gif) ![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) RE: So being off-duty matters after all?,
Ishuli ,
20-Sep-17 09:17 PM, #35
![](./images/mesg_level.gif) RE: So being off-duty matters after all?,
sleepy,
20-Sep-17 09:34 PM, #42
![](./images/middle_mesg_level.gif) ![](./images/mesg_level.gif) RE: So being off-duty matters after all?,
Ishuli ,
20-Sep-17 09:53 PM, #45
![](./images/middle_mesg_level.gif) ![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) Fellow 2L checking in!,
Andrlos,
21-Sep-17 05:51 AM, #56
![](./images/mesg_level.gif) Three law students? You poor bastards :),
lasentia,
22-Sep-17 08:56 AM, #63
![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) RE: Fellow 2L checking in!,
sleepy,
22-Sep-17 02:34 PM, #66
![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) RE: Fellow 2L checking in!,
Andrlos,
22-Sep-17 05:29 PM, #67
![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) RE: Fellow 2L checking in!,
sleepy,
22-Sep-17 10:38 PM, #68
![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) RE: So being off-duty matters after all?,
Kstatida,
21-Sep-17 05:15 AM, #55
![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) RE: So being off-duty matters after all?,
Jarmel,
20-Sep-17 09:04 PM, #30
![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) I mean...,
sleepy,
20-Sep-17 09:15 PM, #33
![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) RE: I mean...,
Jarmel,
20-Sep-17 09:33 PM, #41
![](./images/mesg_level.gif) RE: I mean...,
sleepy,
20-Sep-17 09:38 PM, #43
![](./images/middle_mesg_level.gif) ![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) RE: I mean...,
Jarmel,
21-Sep-17 12:38 AM, #50
![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) My example was terrible Criminal A Criminal B,
Jarmel,
21-Sep-17 12:43 AM, #51
![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) Tribunal library. Look for Precedents :-D,
Quixotic,
20-Sep-17 07:00 PM, #19
![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) RE: Exactly,
Jarmel,
20-Sep-17 06:22 PM, #18
![](./images/mesg_level.gif) 4b with some investigation can allow a flag. 8 doesn't,
Murphy,
20-Sep-17 07:54 PM, #20
![](./images/middle_mesg_level.gif) ![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) RE: 4b with some investigation can allow a flag. 8 does...,
Jarmel,
20-Sep-17 08:45 PM, #24
![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) Are you just deliberately misinterpreting my words?,
Murphy,
20-Sep-17 09:05 PM, #31
![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) I simply quoted you first and questioned what was said,
Jarmel,
20-Sep-17 09:18 PM, #36
![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) See post #37.,
Murphy,
20-Sep-17 09:27 PM, #38
![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) RE: See post #48.,
Jarmel,
21-Sep-17 12:54 AM, #52
![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) RE: Exactly,
sleepy,
20-Sep-17 08:33 PM, #23
![](./images/mesg_level.gif) He argues that your intent doesn't matter,
Murphy,
20-Sep-17 08:49 PM, #25
![](./images/middle_mesg_level.gif) ![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) Focus on my example first ...,
Jarmel,
20-Sep-17 09:00 PM, #29
![](./images/mesg_level.gif) RE: Exactly,
Jarmel,
20-Sep-17 08:58 PM #27
![](./images/middle_mesg_level.gif) ![](./images/mesg_level.gif) RE: Exactly,
sleepy,
20-Sep-17 09:16 PM, #32
![](./images/middle_mesg_level.gif) ![](./images/middle_mesg_level.gif) ![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) RE: Exactly,
Jarmel,
20-Sep-17 09:16 PM, #34
![](./images/middle_mesg_level.gif) ![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) That doesn't really answer the Q,
sleepy,
20-Sep-17 09:24 PM, #40
![](./images/middle_mesg_level.gif) ![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) RE: That doesn't really answer the Q,
Jarmel,
20-Sep-17 10:06 PM, #46
![](./images/middle_mesg_level.gif) ![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) That line in the sand cannot be drawn the way you draw ...,
Murphy,
20-Sep-17 09:19 PM, #37
![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) RE: That line in the sand cannot be drawn the way you d...,
Jarmel,
20-Sep-17 09:48 PM, #44
![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) Here's what I imagined that can justify a flag:,
Murphy,
20-Sep-17 10:31 PM, #47
![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) I can see your point,
Jarmel,
20-Sep-17 11:57 PM, #48
![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) What if...,
sleepy,
21-Sep-17 01:42 AM, #53
![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) RE: What if...,
Jarmel,
25-Sep-17 10:36 PM, #69
![](./images/last_mesg_level.gif) Ok I have got this now,
Jarmel,
21-Sep-17 12:18 AM, #49
| |
|