The mageslayer was until recently the best killer of mages in the cabal. While that leaves some room for interpertation when the race is close this race was nowhere near close.

Lohak 88 mage kills - 1.72 Gank
Mauz 43 mage kills - 2.14 Gank

Thats pretty much it. To me this is like installing someone as president who came in a distant 4th in the election just because the people who did the seating liked the way he ran his campaign and ignored all of the actual data in front of them.


As a side note the % of kills as mage should not be counted. That has so much to do with the composition of enemies and your build that you can't really filter that bias out. For instance a duergar warrior should see a lower mage kill % just because a lot more non village enemies will be coming after them as opposed to a N/N arial thief.

If I were to try and figure out who the best scorer in basketball is I am not going to go much further then the stat sheet for free throws, 2 pointers, and 3 pointers. Might argue about why the guy with more 3's and less free throws that is in a close second deserves the top spot but if that number one guy more then doubles number 2 it takes the wind out of pretty much any argument. Thats a ####ing huge difference.


Keep in mind up until now the system has worked. In this case the admin (mortal and immortal) failed hard in their duty to police Lohaks behavior. I don't think there needs to be any sweeping changes to the system this was just one instance where someone dropped the ball and tried to make up for it after the fact by denying a reward. Unfortunatly in doing so they undermined the legitamacy of the reward.