Subject: "Generalizing the problem" Previous topic | Next topic
Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend CF Website
Top General Discussions Gameplay Topic #19760
Show all folders

Terwin05Mon 26-Nov-07 02:09 PM
Member since 22nd Dec 2005
124 posts
Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this author Click to view this author's profile Click to add this author to your buddy list
#19802, "Generalizing the problem"


          

First, I'd like to plug my post on the Santa Zulg forum regarding making cabalwars more interesting. This idea is just an extension of that.

http://forums.carrionfields.com/dc/dcboard.php?az=show_topic&forum=58&topic_id=12

Problem: Lowbies are useless in cabalwars.

Reason: They can't kill the guardians that hold the items.

Solution: Make more items. Voltron had five lions and Captain Planet's teenage posse had five rings, so why not have five "items" per cabal? Adding to that further, why not have three (or even four) of those items be usable by any cabal?

I should add, and the imms are probably aware, one of the aforementioned CF spinoffs implemented such a system, although in their case all "items of power" were generalized. It was just a question of how many each cabal had at any one time.

I think the idea can be taken further by having these generalized items being a subset of the "cabal items" group, which would still include the unique items we have today. In addition, these generalized items should be able to be transfered by pking cabal members - and anybody should be able to do it.

So I kill level 18 rager X, perform some ritual over his corpse, and receive *special item* as a result. This would obviously be modified so that multikilling wouldn't yield more of these items (if the cabal had more to give). Also, you might even throw a bone to the pkilled by having the ritual destroy his corpse and return the eq a la areas explore.

The poseession of these generic cabal items would equate with the levels of cabal powers I discussed in the Santa Zulg post.

Now as for where and how these items might pop up, I'm open to suggestion.

Thoughts? We need to give lowbies something to do in cabal wars. If they can help out the team by pking members of other cabals, that would be a great start. In addition, it plays into the rp elements that I was suggesting in the other post. A lowbie imperial is happy to let lowbie tribs live because hey, we're all orderly here. What if the imperial could gank down a lowbie trib and pull an item of power (admittedly less power than the Scales, but hey, it's something) from the corpse of the trib? Alliances suddenly mean a lot more, and roles become much more important.

Glad that you're thinking about this, Nep. I think a big change to the system could really make things more interesting for players of all levels. And as an even more interesting side-effect, could allow further decentralization of cabal wars (read: more cabals) without diluting the fun.

T

  

Alert | IP Printer Friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote

HOT TopicCabals [View all] , Daevryn, Sun 25-Nov-07 09:10 PM
Reply RE: Cabals, Eskelian, 03-Dec-07 02:49 AM, #100
Reply My thoughts..., trewyn, 27-Nov-07 11:03 PM, #72
Reply I agree that getting inducted should not be time consum..., elmeri_, 28-Nov-07 09:33 AM, #77
Reply RE: Cabals, Doge, 27-Nov-07 12:31 PM, #60
Reply Changes to cabal raiding I would like to see, elmeri_, 27-Nov-07 06:54 AM, #56
Reply Continued, elmeri_, 27-Nov-07 10:06 AM, #59
     Reply I think this might have some merit, and is certainly ea..., Quixotic, 27-Nov-07 01:14 PM, #62
     Reply RE: Continued, _Magus_, 27-Nov-07 02:58 PM, #63
          Reply RE: Continued, Tac, 27-Nov-07 03:52 PM, #64
          Reply RE: Continued, Daevryn, 27-Nov-07 04:13 PM, #66
               Reply That's just the thing., elmeri_, 27-Nov-07 05:06 PM, #67
               Reply RE: That's just the thing., Daevryn, 27-Nov-07 05:14 PM, #68
                    Reply I'm not talking about scaled effects though, elmeri_, 27-Nov-07 07:09 PM, #69
                         Reply It's just... too complicated., Terwin05, 27-Nov-07 08:39 PM, #70
                              Reply Well, just ditch whatever I said about raiding empty ca..., elmeri_, 28-Nov-07 03:54 AM, #76
               Reply Show me your log of you solo'ing the Scion Archmage ple..., trewyn, 27-Nov-07 10:52 PM, #71
               Reply I was able to solo the Archmage rather easily..., _Magus_, 28-Nov-07 03:02 AM, #74
               Reply I've got to ask then...., Tac, 28-Nov-07 09:47 AM, #78
               Reply RE: I've got to ask then...., Daevryn, 28-Nov-07 10:20 AM, #79
                    Reply RE: I've got to ask then...., Tac, 28-Nov-07 10:53 AM, #80
                    Reply RE: I've got to ask then...., Daevryn, 28-Nov-07 02:01 PM, #87
                    Reply RE: I've got to ask then...., Tac, 28-Nov-07 02:49 PM, #91
                         Reply RE: I've got to ask then...., Daevryn, 28-Nov-07 03:35 PM, #96
                    Reply Not to get off on too much of a tangent, _Magus_, 28-Nov-07 02:20 PM, #88
                    Reply RE: Not to get off on too much of a tangent, Daevryn, 28-Nov-07 02:22 PM, #89
                    Reply Builds that will destroy inners., elmeri_, 28-Nov-07 02:49 PM, #90
                    Reply Ok, help. What am I missing?, Adhelard, 28-Nov-07 12:50 PM, #81
                         Reply try a ranger if you want real humility in raiding, Trouble, 28-Nov-07 01:13 PM, #82
                         Reply RE: try a ranger if you want real humility in raiding, Daevryn, 28-Nov-07 01:21 PM, #84
                         Reply RE: try a ranger if you want real humility in raiding, Adhelard, 28-Nov-07 03:05 PM, #93
                              Reply RE: try a ranger if you want real humility in raiding, Daevryn, 28-Nov-07 03:26 PM, #95
                         Reply RE: Ok, help. What am I missing?, Daevryn, 28-Nov-07 01:18 PM, #83
                              Reply RE: Ok, help. What am I missing?, Adhelard, 28-Nov-07 03:03 PM, #92
                                   Reply RE: Ok, help. What am I missing?, Daevryn, 28-Nov-07 03:23 PM, #94
                                        Reply Ok, thanks., Adhelard, 29-Nov-07 06:23 PM, #98
               Reply RE: Continued, TJHuron, 30-Nov-07 12:55 AM, #99
          Reply They would not be able to slay it at will, elmeri_, 27-Nov-07 04:06 PM, #65
Reply Generalizing the problem, Terwin05, 26-Nov-07 02:09 PM #42
Reply RE: Generalizing the problem, Dervish, 26-Nov-07 02:16 PM, #45
Reply RE: Outposts, DurNominator, 26-Nov-07 03:58 PM, #49
Reply I like Magus and Boon's combined Ideas., Dragomir, 26-Nov-07 01:45 PM, #38
Reply RE: I like Magus and Boon's combined Ideas., _Magus_, 26-Nov-07 02:04 PM, #41
Reply RE: Cabals, Twist, 26-Nov-07 11:21 AM, #22
Reply Another cause is pb caution, Theerkla, 26-Nov-07 11:31 AM, #23
Reply RE: Another cause is pb caution, Daevryn, 26-Nov-07 11:40 AM, #24
     Reply RE: Another cause is pb caution, Torak, 26-Nov-07 01:05 PM, #30
Reply RE: Cabals, Daevryn, 26-Nov-07 12:01 PM, #25
Reply Well there you go..., Tac, 26-Nov-07 12:31 PM, #26
     Reply RE: Well there you go..., Daevryn, 26-Nov-07 12:41 PM, #27
     Reply You aren't the only one..., Tac, 26-Nov-07 12:57 PM, #28
     Reply RE: You aren't the only one..., Daevryn, 26-Nov-07 01:12 PM, #33
     Reply Almost been there, done that.., Trouble, 26-Nov-07 01:04 PM, #31
     Reply RE: Almost been there, done that.., Daevryn, 26-Nov-07 01:10 PM, #32
          Reply Hmm, wonder where I got that from., Trouble, 26-Nov-07 01:30 PM, #35
               Reply RE: Hmm, wonder where I got that from., Daevryn, 26-Nov-07 01:43 PM, #37
                    Reply Heh, you missed the important part..., Tac, 26-Nov-07 02:11 PM, #44
                         Reply How about more rewarding in general? -nt-, Mekantos, 26-Nov-07 04:08 PM, #51
                              Reply I think there's been less rewarding since the installme..., _Magus_, 28-Nov-07 03:35 AM, #75
     Reply Nope!!, trewyn, 27-Nov-07 11:36 PM, #73
     Reply Dont do it please and here is why, Dervish, 26-Nov-07 01:01 PM, #29
Reply Glass Houses + Brick = goofy idea on retrieval, UncleArzzra, 26-Nov-07 01:52 PM, #39
Reply RE: Cabals, Kalageadon, 28-Nov-07 05:15 PM, #97
Reply RE: Cabals, Chalupah, 12-Dec-07 04:16 PM, #102
Reply RE: Cabals, incognito, 26-Nov-07 03:48 AM, #15
Reply I concur, ORB, 26-Nov-07 04:42 AM, #16
Reply I may be mistaken but, Dervish, 26-Nov-07 05:21 AM, #17
Reply I'm talking most people in the cabal by lvl 15. not an ..., ORB, 27-Nov-07 08:31 AM, #57
Reply RE: Getting back to the good ole' days:, _Magus_, 26-Nov-07 08:17 PM, #55
Reply Eh:, Daevryn, 26-Nov-07 08:58 AM, #19
     Reply RE: Eh:, Dervish, 26-Nov-07 09:38 AM, #20
     Reply The Five Magics, Twist, 26-Nov-07 11:00 AM, #21
          Reply Nice story..., Dervish, 26-Nov-07 01:13 PM, #34
          Reply RE: Nice story..., Twist, 26-Nov-07 03:38 PM, #48
          Reply The *real* Five Magics, Trouble, 26-Nov-07 01:42 PM, #36
               Reply You were in charge of both..., Twist, 26-Nov-07 03:34 PM, #47
                    Reply Only if you use the phrase 'in charge' loosely., Trouble, 28-Nov-07 01:40 PM, #85
                         Reply Poofin..., Twist, 28-Nov-07 01:46 PM, #86
     Reply RE: Eh:, incognito, 26-Nov-07 02:38 PM, #46
Reply Some ideas for you, Mekantos, 26-Nov-07 01:39 AM, #13
Reply Is there any love for this idea? If yes, I will build o..., Mekantos, 26-Nov-07 04:03 PM, #50
     Reply I don't speak for everyone, but..., Twist, 27-Nov-07 09:06 AM, #58
Reply Suggestions, Torak, 25-Nov-07 11:24 PM, #9
Reply a few points and ideas, Quixotic, 25-Nov-07 10:43 PM, #6
Reply RE: a few points and ideas, Daevryn, 25-Nov-07 10:55 PM, #7
     Reply True., Quixotic, 25-Nov-07 11:05 PM, #8
Reply Two answers:, UncleArzzra, 25-Nov-07 10:25 PM, #4
Reply Re: Cabal Reputation, _Magus_, 25-Nov-07 10:32 PM, #5
Reply RE: Cabals, _Magus_, 25-Nov-07 09:52 PM, #1
     Reply RE: Cabals, Boon, 25-Nov-07 10:32 PM, #2
     Reply Cool. Thanks for expounding on the idea. ~, _Magus_, 25-Nov-07 10:16 PM, #3
     Reply Your idea deserves merit at the least., Derexal, 25-Nov-07 11:26 PM, #10
     Reply RE: Your idea deserves merit at the least., _Magus_, 26-Nov-07 02:09 PM, #43
     Reply RE: Cabals, silencedstatik, 26-Nov-07 12:37 AM, #11
     Reply RE: Skill ideas?, _Magus_, 26-Nov-07 01:01 AM, #12
     Reply I dont like it., Dervish, 26-Nov-07 03:31 AM, #14
     Reply RE: I dont like it., Daevryn, 26-Nov-07 08:56 AM, #18
     Reply RE: I dont like it., Amaranthe, 27-Nov-07 12:32 PM, #61
     Reply RE: I dont like it., Lyristeon, 26-Nov-07 04:26 PM, #52
          Reply Hey, said "A" say "B"?, Dervish, 26-Nov-07 04:57 PM, #53
               Reply RE: Unique bonuses, _Magus_, 26-Nov-07 08:12 PM, #54
     Reply An added thought:, _Magus_, 26-Nov-07 01:59 PM, #40
     Reply I don't like this..., Eskelian, 03-Dec-07 03:03 AM, #101
Top General Discussions Gameplay Topic #19760 Previous topic | Next topic