1. You're interpreting rules in a certain way. They aren't fixed in the way in you want.

2. Serial battle player who was a newbie spending hundreds of hours dying to necromancers and antipaladins without getting inducted (my first battle char ever got inducted with 12 con left), imho the system is fine as is.

3. Beyond intepreting the rules a certain way, you're assuming the rules apply to people who aren't yet in the village. That's also another example of shoving your ideas onto other people's roleplay.

There's always an evil trib or two, for example, who pkills in the city without being caught before being inducted. For some reason, I don't see you posting about this.