>Joe Maran was evil at the time of his crime(due to the mass
>nature of the event, though the perception thing may scewer it
>to neutral, but definitely not a goodie). If a Fort Imm saw
>it, it might result to Joe Maran getting booted and turned
>neutral. Because of the Scion involvement, Joe Maran would
>have a chance to redeem his act to return to Light. However,
>the Imm's can't spectate Joe 24/7, so it might be so that Joe
>is forgiven, as it could happen that the Imm responsible would
>never see Joe again.

Then we just fundamentally disagree on how alignment should work. I consider Joe to be unquestionably "good-aligned" throughout the whole ordeal. He never wavered from acting as a "good-aligned" person should, given his perception of reality (which was altered). You can't be "accidentally" evil.