Daurwyn on Rogue's usual traits:
>Then carry out the usual "camo, deaf, ambush, talk crap, camo, deaf,
>ambush stuff". My impression is that Careashin was better than this,
>but based on the feedback I am now under the impression that he fit
>the usual mould.

Granted, I wasn't an enemy and I think the foe vs. foe relation is very important, but it was my impression that Careashin was much more than a griefer character.

I'll admit first hand that I found his antics extremely annoying, but I don't necessarily see that as a bad thing. He was the genuine trickster personage and as such fit perfectly into the outlander mold and wouldn't work as tribunal, as you seem to suggest he could have.

Furthermore he was very active, always out there doing something. I never heard him say something stupid over cb or bitch in person. Also he struck me as genuinely unpredictable, which is rather rare.

Dunno. I understand the 'but this is just the usual Rogue' argument, but I consider it hard to pull off a real trickster personage and I think Rogue did just that and did it well.