Murphy | Sun 10-Sep-17 10:12 AM |
Member since 30th Dec 2010
1639 posts
| |
|
#132272, "I will quote the helpfile (emphasis mine)"
Edited on Sun 10-Sep-17 10:20 AM
|
"Often a Provost may be seen around Thera with an honor guard of lieutenants at his or her side. However, the Provost is still off duty when outside of the cities. Accordingly, it is NEVER illegal to attack the Provost outside of a protected city, whether they have lieutenants with them or not."
Helpfiles > Spire books
And it's not clear at all whether by attacking you I'm helping a criminal or not. It may be clear to you in your head but it should also be unambiguous to any other player. Flags are a big deal and especially as a Trib you should strive to make it absolutely clear for people what's going to lead to a flag and what isn't.
Instead, you intentionally create ambiguity because "helping a criminal" is so super vague. If you're attacking a cabal outer to get to a criminal, and I'm in that cabal, does the law forbid me from defending my home?
|
|
|
(DELETED) [TRIBUNAL] Lochlan McFae the Spectre, Provinc...
[View all] , Death_Angel, Fri 25-Aug-17 11:32 AM
Locked due to off topic clutter.,
Jormyr,
12-Sep-17 03:26 AM, #92
My bad,
Kstatida,
09-Sep-17 03:16 PM, #48
RE: My bad,
lochlan (Anonymous),
09-Sep-17 03:37 PM, #50
RE: (DELETED) [TRIBUNAL] Lochlan McFae the Spectre, Pro...,
some more goodbies (Anonymous),
08-Sep-17 11:49 PM, #26
RE: (DELETED) [TRIBUNAL] Lochlan McFae the Spectre, Pro...,
Vehli (Anonymous),
09-Sep-17 04:47 AM, #30
RE: (DELETED) [TRIBUNAL] Lochlan McFae the Spectre, Pro...,
lochlan (Anonymous),
09-Sep-17 07:28 AM, #32
My intention never was to grief you,
Vehli (Anonymous),
09-Sep-17 01:21 PM, #42
RE: My intention never was to grief you,
lochlan (Anonymous),
09-Sep-17 01:56 PM, #44
RE: My intention never was to grief you,
Vehli (Anonymous),
09-Sep-17 07:34 PM, #53
Glad to see this,
IdiotCFer (NOT Outlander),
01-Sep-17 12:29 PM, #16
You yourself are cancer, friendo. n/t,
Lhydia,
01-Sep-17 02:26 PM, #17
RE: Glad to see this,
lochlan (Anonymous),
08-Sep-17 10:15 PM, #18
First of all...,
Yanni Sunburst (Anonymous),
09-Sep-17 12:16 PM, #38
RE: First of all...,
lochlan (Anonymous),
09-Sep-17 12:27 PM, #39
Um... huh?,
Seriphax,
09-Sep-17 01:51 PM, #43
RE: Um... huh?,
lochlan (Anonymous),
09-Sep-17 01:57 PM, #45
To be expected.,
Seriphax,
09-Sep-17 02:51 PM, #46
RE: To be expected.,
lochlan (Anonymous),
09-Sep-17 03:31 PM, #49
You took the orb as a trib?,
Murphy,
09-Sep-17 09:02 PM, #55
RE: You took the orb as a trib?,
lochlan (Anonymous),
09-Sep-17 11:09 PM, #57
Attacking a cabal, yes,
Murphy,
10-Sep-17 03:53 AM, #61
RE: Attacking a cabal, yes,
lochlan (Anonymous),
10-Sep-17 09:40 AM, #62
Just because the books allow it,
Murphy,
10-Sep-17 10:07 AM, #64
Which means it's down to Vindicator's judgment,
Kstatida,
10-Sep-17 01:15 PM, #68
Yes, it's down to Vindicator's judgment,
Murphy,
10-Sep-17 08:13 PM, #71
Alas, no date for you.,
Ishuli,
28-Aug-17 03:11 PM, #7
I don't want to HJ this thread but he's not even postin...,
sleepy,
29-Aug-17 12:37 AM, #8
Because..,
Lhydia,
29-Aug-17 05:52 AM, #9
So much this NT,
Kstatida,
29-Aug-17 07:20 AM, #10
RE: I don't want to HJ this thread but he's not even po...,
Ishuli,
29-Aug-17 10:19 AM, #11
Question then. ,
Lhydia,
29-Aug-17 11:41 AM, #12
RE: Question then. ,
Ishuli,
29-Aug-17 12:18 PM, #13
Oh yeah?,
Murphy,
29-Aug-17 09:40 PM, #14
RE: Oh yeah?,
Ishuli,
30-Aug-17 10:43 AM, #15
RE: Oh yeah?,
Murphy,
09-Sep-17 12:18 AM, #28
It is exactly the same as far as the code is concerned.,
Seriphax,
09-Sep-17 03:04 PM, #47
In my case,
Murphy,
09-Sep-17 09:17 PM, #56
RE: In my case,
galkabear,
09-Sep-17 11:22 PM, #58
RE: In my case,
Murphy,
10-Sep-17 04:05 AM, #60
RE: In my case,
lochlan (Anonymous),
10-Sep-17 09:51 AM, #63
I will quote the helpfile (emphasis mine),
Murphy,
10-Sep-17 10:20 AM #65
RE: I will quote the helpfile (emphasis mine),
crom,
10-Sep-17 10:39 AM, #66
Would, but shouldn't.,
Murphy,
10-Sep-17 11:02 AM, #67
RE: Would, but shouldn't.,
lochlan (Anonymous),
10-Sep-17 03:52 PM, #69
Nonsense,
Murphy,
10-Sep-17 08:12 PM, #70
RE: Nonsense,
Lochlan (Anonymous),
10-Sep-17 11:18 PM, #72
Jurisdiction applies to all laws, again, see off-duty b...,
Murphy,
10-Sep-17 11:48 PM, #73
RE: Jurisdiction applies to all laws, again, see off-du...,
lochlan (Anonymous),
11-Sep-17 08:44 AM, #74
Nope,
Murphy,
11-Sep-17 09:03 AM, #75
RE: Nope,
Jarmel,
11-Sep-17 05:56 PM, #76
Common sense,
Murphy,
11-Sep-17 09:15 PM, #77
RE: Common sense,
Jarmel,
11-Sep-17 09:57 PM, #79
RE: Common sense,
Saagkri,
11-Sep-17 10:05 PM, #80
RE: Common sense,
Jarmel,
11-Sep-17 10:37 PM, #85
There's a million situations,
Murphy,
11-Sep-17 11:02 PM, #86
RE: Common sense,
lochlan (Anonymous),
11-Sep-17 10:36 PM, #84
RE: Nope,
lochlan (Anonymous),
11-Sep-17 10:13 PM, #81
RE: Nonsense,
Saagkri,
11-Sep-17 09:38 PM, #78
RE: Nonsense,
lochlan (Anonymous),
11-Sep-17 10:23 PM, #82
RE: Nonsense,
Saagkri,
12-Sep-17 12:20 AM, #87
RE: Nonsense,
Jarmel,
12-Sep-17 01:09 AM, #88
That remark is for Law #3,
Murphy,
12-Sep-17 01:28 AM, #89
And here's Nep's word on it,
Murphy,
12-Sep-17 01:34 AM, #90
Putting Jurisdiction issues into HELP LAW,
Kstatida,
12-Sep-17 03:00 AM, #91
RE: Nonsense,
Jarmel,
11-Sep-17 10:30 PM, #83
that was speculation,
lochlan (Anonymous),
08-Sep-17 10:32 PM, #20
RE: that was speculation,
sleepy,
09-Sep-17 05:06 AM, #31
RE: that was speculation,
lochlan (Anonymous),
09-Sep-17 07:32 AM, #33
RE: Alas, no date for you.,
lochlan (Anonymous),
08-Sep-17 10:25 PM, #19
To be fair, 45/50 of your PWKs were me. n/t,
IAmStevers,
09-Sep-17 01:13 AM, #29
RE: To be fair, 45/50 of your PWKs were me. n/t,
lochlan (Anonymous),
09-Sep-17 07:39 AM, #34
Completely wrong about assassinate.,
Lhydia,
09-Sep-17 08:54 AM, #35
RE: Completely wrong about assassinate.,
lochlan (Anonymous),
09-Sep-17 09:22 AM, #36
Many many many things have changed since then. ,
Lhydia,
09-Sep-17 09:26 AM, #37
RE: Many many many things have changed since then. ,
lochlan (Anonymous),
09-Sep-17 12:28 PM, #40
It's cool. Good character bye the way. n/t,
Lhydia,
09-Sep-17 03:40 PM, #51
RE: It's cool. Good character bye the way. n/t,
lochlan (Anonymous),
09-Sep-17 06:10 PM, #52
I'm good.,
Lhydia,
09-Sep-17 07:36 PM, #54
RE: I'm good.,
lochlan (Anonymous),
09-Sep-17 11:41 PM, #59
I'm curious to know those edges lol :P n/t,
Blkdrgn,
09-Sep-17 12:34 PM, #41
Props for being a long lived specter ,
laxman,
25-Aug-17 10:30 PM, #6
RE: Props for being a long lived specter ,
lochlan (Anonymous),
08-Sep-17 10:39 PM, #21
RE: Props for being a long lived specter ,
Blkdrgn,
08-Sep-17 11:32 PM, #25
RE: Props for being a long lived specter ,
lochlan (Anonymous),
08-Sep-17 11:57 PM, #27
RE: (DELETED) [TRIBUNAL] Lochlan McFae the Spectre, Pro...,
Rahsael,
25-Aug-17 04:43 PM, #4
Oh,
Kstatida,
25-Aug-17 04:49 PM, #5
RE: (DELETED) [TRIBUNAL] Lochlan McFae the Spectre, Pro...,
lochlan (Anonymous),
08-Sep-17 10:46 PM, #22
You said you only gone for a while!,
Pticriss (Anonymous),
25-Aug-17 03:30 PM, #2
That's probably what happened. n/t,
Lhydia,
25-Aug-17 04:12 PM, #3
RE: You said you only gone for a while!,
lochlan (Anonymous),
08-Sep-17 10:54 PM, #23
Missed adventure,
Aroyv Undersnake (Anonymous),
25-Aug-17 02:57 PM, #1
RE: Missed adventure,
lochlan (Anonymous),
08-Sep-17 10:56 PM, #24
| |
|