My saves presently look like this:

vs Spell : -63 Divinely protected vs Paralysis: -20 Somewhat protected
vs Breath : -23 Protected vs Mental : 0 Not protected


The AP player I'm fighting is failing lots of spells, but 'deafen' works on the first shot, always.

Just wondering if this is intended.

Very possible that 'deafen' checks for a different save - but if it's meant to check for 'save vs spell', it definitely has 100% success date.