Subject: "Thanks." Previous topic | Next topic
Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend CF Website
Top General Discussions Gameplay Topic #57251
Show all folders

TMNSTue 23-Dec-14 09:25 PM
Member since 10th Jun 2009
2670 posts
Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this author Click to view this author's profile Click to add this author to your buddy list
#57494, "Thanks."


          

>Let me start by saying that the number of edges that characters, as a whole, have had gotten completely out of control.<

Had been saying that for years. The idea in principle was excellent (new ways to customize every character!) but in execution it left a lot to be desired.

As you mentioned, I can't imagine the original thought behind edges would allow certain characters to have soooo many. The idea (in principle from what I could glean from forum conversations) behind them was to make a weakness less of a weakness or make a strength slightly stronger. That's a great idea...but, you have to have checks and balances for that idea. I shouldn't be able to cover ALL of my weaknesses and make ALL of my strengths stronger.

I always thought edge points should be capped. You should only be able to get 5-7 edges total for a character, and they should be ranked in tiers. You get can take 2-3 from tier 1, 1-2 from tier 2, 1 max from tier 3 (tier 3 would be edges like Devious Versatility that impart a significant amount of power to a character).

Anywhoo, hope everyone is well, and hope the Holidays treats everyone well.

  

Alert | IP Printer Friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote

HOT TopicEdge Point Changes [View all] , Whiysdan, Wed 03-Dec-14 07:09 AM
Reply Thanks., TMNS, 23-Dec-14 09:25 PM #47
Reply How nice of you to go out of your way, Murphy, 24-Dec-14 11:02 PM, #48
     Reply RE: How nice of you to go out of your way, Cleauseau, 25-Dec-14 03:25 AM, #49
          Reply Nothing to do with PKs. I just hate inconvenience., Murphy, 25-Dec-14 04:21 AM, #50
               Reply RE: Nothing to do with PKs. I just hate inconvenience., Purmodin, 25-Dec-14 07:45 PM, #51
                    Reply I have already adapted, I'm just calling out Sam., Murphy, 25-Dec-14 08:01 PM, #52
Reply RE: Edge Point Changes, mackle, 05-Dec-14 05:10 PM, #46
Reply RE: Edge Point Changes, Demos, 04-Dec-14 05:42 PM, #43
Reply Am I in the minority on edges?, Amora, 03-Dec-14 11:07 PM, #32
Reply You aren't alone, Sarien, 04-Dec-14 08:39 AM, #37
Reply RE: Am I in the minority on edges?, incognito, 04-Dec-14 08:57 AM, #38
Reply Obviously you aren't in the minority, Murphy, 04-Dec-14 10:22 AM, #39
     Reply Not convinced, incognito, 04-Dec-14 01:25 PM, #40
          Reply Those were just examples, Murphy, 04-Dec-14 01:49 PM, #41
               Reply RE: Those were just examples, Daevryn, 05-Dec-14 12:28 AM, #45
Reply Love this change!, DeathIncarnate, 03-Dec-14 06:31 PM, #26
Reply RE: Edge Point Changes, Hutto, 03-Dec-14 06:16 PM, #23
Reply RE: Edge Point Changes, Bemused, 03-Dec-14 06:05 PM, #25
Reply RE: Edge Point Changes, Daevryn, 03-Dec-14 10:21 PM, #30
     Reply Can we revisit the idea of imm exp on silent tower pret..., Anti-Hero, 03-Dec-14 11:04 PM, #31
Reply Informed Decisions, laxman, 03-Dec-14 09:50 AM, #13
Reply On this note, incognito, 03-Dec-14 01:30 PM, #17
Reply Just out of curiosity, Pendragon_Surtr, 03-Dec-14 09:20 AM, #10
Reply Impossible to say., Umiron, 03-Dec-14 09:39 AM, #12
Reply RE: Impossible to say., Pendragon_Surtr, 03-Dec-14 12:13 PM, #16
     Reply Not that simple, incognito, 03-Dec-14 01:32 PM, #18
          Reply RE: Not that simple, Daevryn, 03-Dec-14 09:49 PM, #28
Reply RE: Just out of curiosity, Daevryn, 03-Dec-14 09:56 PM, #29
     Reply I must have been on good drugs I guess, Pendragon_Surtr, 03-Dec-14 11:27 PM, #33
Reply Please provide alternate routes for edges that aren't I..., Sarien, 03-Dec-14 07:40 AM, #8
Reply RE: Please provide alternate routes for edges that aren..., Akresius, 03-Dec-14 09:08 AM, #9
     Reply Crap, I screwed that up., Sarien, 03-Dec-14 10:27 AM, #14
          Reply RE: Crap, I screwed that up., Daevryn, 03-Dec-14 09:46 PM, #27
               Reply My impression, incognito, 04-Dec-14 02:31 AM, #34
               Reply RE: My impression, Daevryn, 05-Dec-14 12:24 AM, #44
               Reply I guess I must have missed it., Sarien, 04-Dec-14 07:53 AM, #36
                    Reply Not sure I like the edges for killing mobs, incognito, 04-Dec-14 02:54 PM, #42
Reply RE: Edge Point Changes, Bemused, 02-Dec-14 06:17 PM, #7
Reply RE: Edge Point Changes, Whiysdan, 02-Dec-14 07:04 PM, #4
Reply Allysia & Salyeris and thoughts on a point system, lasentia, 03-Dec-14 09:31 AM, #11
     Reply You nailed it right there., Murphy, 03-Dec-14 11:36 AM, #15
     Reply Except, I never see any edges as essential, lasentia, 03-Dec-14 02:05 PM, #19
          Reply A couple are a mechanical neccesity, laxman, 03-Dec-14 04:36 PM, #20
          Reply A thought on slaver, Tac, 03-Dec-14 04:55 PM, #21
               Reply my thoughts on slaver, laxman, 03-Dec-14 05:09 PM, #22
          Reply The thing about ap edges, incognito, 04-Dec-14 02:35 AM, #35
     Reply RE: Allysia & Salyeris and thoughts on a point system, Bemused, 03-Dec-14 05:59 PM, #24
Reply Why not halve the cap instead of halving the returns?, Murphy, 03-Dec-14 06:17 AM, #6
Reply Thanks for all you do. I retract my original comments u..., polmier, 02-Dec-14 06:14 PM, #2
Reply Thanks for your thanks! (n/t), Whiysdan, 02-Dec-14 07:04 PM, #5
Reply RE: Edge Point Changes, N b M, 02-Dec-14 05:58 PM, #1
     Reply RE: Edge Point Changes, Whiysdan, 02-Dec-14 07:00 PM, #3
Top General Discussions Gameplay Topic #57251 Previous topic | Next topic