...and I'm going from (poor, old-man) memory, but in general I think it went like this:

Early years up through lichquest - most comments were positive or neutral.

I believe Lyristeon ran your lichquest. I could be wrong. I know it wasn't me. The crown of Mu was likely a form of a red herring, or the EEC acting crazy again, or some such. I'm not certain, it's nothing I've ever heard of though.

Immediately post-lichquest, some/most of the commentary was negative, about your extreme conservative playstyle. This was even after the "needing to build up some phylacteries" phase.

Later commentary was generally positive or neutral again - the above was likely a difference in opinion by those who made the comments and you as to what a "good set of phylacteries" consisted of.

In-game, I think your chars and mind generally had a healthy respect for each other (if they interacted much at all).

On the forums, I think you posted positively about folks who gleefully died to you, so long as they stuck to their role, and you posted semi-negatively about folks who refused to give you more phylacs (either through conservative play that meant exiting combat once you had a chance to PWK or refusing to fight you (without a gang)).

I really can't fault you for anything ON CF, other than that talk I had with you and that other person, wayyy back. Folks who talked about russian permas weren't noticing, as I was, how Dargin (for instance) was as hot to kill you (with good schemes to do so) as anyone I've seen this side of Ilix/Cyrn.

Good luck with the next one.