Subject: "It isn't just you. Once I got past the" Previous topic | Next topic
Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend CF Website
Top Non-CF Discussion "What Does RL Stand For?" Topic #364
Show all folders

QuixoticFri 15-Sep-06 10:03 PM
Member since 09th Feb 2006
829 posts
Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this author Click to add this author to your buddy list
#414, "It isn't just you. Once I got past the"


          

first novel, with its Terry Brooks-style purple prose and stock heroes, the series developed noir-fantasy themes and increasingly complex plot structures that I absolutely love. Mixed with a sprinkle of allusions to Norse mythology, Arthurian legend and a quiet acknowledgment of the fantasy canon, this series contains some of the best novels I've read.

Unfortunately, as a series I think the Wheel of Time struggles to maintain both focus and forward progress as its axles groan under its own weight. Since the Source has become cleansed and the Final Battle has yet to occur, what should feel like suspense is more like a feeling that Jordan is getting paid by the word: the storyline has become so bloated with characters and subplots as to make the 18 month wait between books to require an eidetic memory or a user-created reference sheet, the text's glossary being nearly worthless after the second novel.

  

Alert | IP Printer Friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote

HOT TopicGood fantasy! [View all] , Crysseara, Thu 14-Sep-06 08:40 PM
Reply RE: Good fantasy!, Pendragon_Surtr, 19-Oct-06 04:50 PM, #49
Reply Read anything I write., (NOT Pro), 19-Oct-06 11:38 AM, #47
Reply RE: Good fantasy!, Algonas, 05-Oct-06 05:47 AM, #46
Reply RE: Good fantasy!, incognito, 28-Sep-06 04:42 PM, #45
Reply RE: Good fantasy!, Moridin, 25-Sep-06 05:34 PM, #43
Reply I second that emotion., (NOT Graatch), 26-Sep-06 02:56 PM, #44
Reply RE: Good fantasy!, Eskelian, 23-Sep-06 12:00 PM, #35
Reply RE: Good fantasy!, DurNominator, 23-Sep-06 01:04 PM, #37
Reply RE: Good fantasy!, Alenysi, 18-Sep-06 11:03 AM, #30
Reply RE: Good fantasy!, DurNominator, 19-Sep-06 03:03 AM, #34
Reply Tigana / Alvin Maker, Valkenar, 18-Sep-06 11:00 AM, #29
Reply RE: Good fantasy!, (NOT Graatch), 18-Sep-06 10:59 AM, #28
Reply Addendum, (NOT Graatch), 18-Sep-06 04:22 PM, #31
Reply Runelords, nepenthe, 18-Sep-06 04:39 PM, #32
     Reply I agree., (NOT Graatch), 18-Sep-06 05:05 PM, #33
Reply Yeah, I'll second Book of Swords series by Fred Saberha..., Eskelian, 23-Sep-06 12:01 PM, #36
Reply Harry Potter!, Marcus_, 18-Sep-06 03:20 AM, #27
Reply RE: Harry Potter!, n8v_nerd, 24-Sep-06 03:53 AM, #39
     Reply Actually, those were written by Chris Claremont., TheLastMohican, 24-Sep-06 11:55 AM, #40
Reply Larry Bond., Grurk Muouk, 17-Sep-06 06:01 PM, #26
Reply RE: Larry Bond., Pico, 24-Sep-06 11:30 PM, #41
     Reply RE: Larry Bond., Grurk Muouk, 25-Sep-06 07:09 AM, #42
Reply Brust, Leiber, Martin, Tim Powers. Done. nt, Larcat, 17-Sep-06 05:36 PM, #25
Reply RE: Good fantasy!, Eshval, 16-Sep-06 11:19 PM, #23
Reply Just a few I've read..., Saith, 16-Sep-06 10:07 PM, #22
Reply Shannara series by Terry Brooks. Start with the sword. ..., dwimmerling, 16-Sep-06 09:19 PM, #21
Reply I really did try!, Crysseara, 17-Sep-06 11:59 AM, #24
Reply Wheel of Time - but maybe thats just me...nt, Minyar, 15-Sep-06 09:16 PM, #18
Reply RE: Wheel of Time - but maybe thats just me...nt, Crysseara, 15-Sep-06 09:57 PM, #19
Reply It isn't just you. Once I got past the, Quixotic, 15-Sep-06 10:03 PM #20
     Reply I hear Jordan isn't doing very well, health-wise., Minyar, 23-Sep-06 03:44 PM, #38
          Reply RE: I hear Jordan isn't doing very well, health-wise., Pendragon_Surtr, 19-Oct-06 04:49 PM, #48
Reply Coldfire Trilogy by CS Friedman., TheLastMohican, 15-Sep-06 07:43 PM, #16
Reply Gaiman, Crysseara, 15-Sep-06 08:43 PM, #17
Reply RE: Good fantasy!, Thrakburzug, 15-Sep-06 07:01 PM, #13
Reply Read Jhereg and the related books by Stephen Brust., Theerkla, 15-Sep-06 02:05 PM, #9
Reply RE: Read Jhereg and the related books by Stephen Brust., nepenthe, 15-Sep-06 05:52 PM, #11
     Reply RE: Read Jhereg and the related books by Stephen Brust., Ishmael, 18-Nov-06 06:40 PM, #50
          Reply Beelzebub as a golden retriever, Theerkla, 18-Nov-06 07:20 PM, #51
Reply If you haven't already., Shadowmaster, 15-Sep-06 11:44 AM, #7
Reply Some of my favorites, Lightmage, 15-Sep-06 11:12 AM, #5
Reply Your old man would appreciate the Spider Queen stuff to..., Lightmage, 15-Sep-06 11:17 AM, #6
Reply AHAH, Vortex Magus, 15-Sep-06 09:03 AM, #3
Reply Ester Friesner, Crysseara, 15-Sep-06 05:33 PM, #10
Reply RE: Good fantasy!, Isildur, 15-Sep-06 12:21 AM, #2
Reply Wherein I blaspheme!, nepenthe, 15-Sep-06 09:50 AM, #4
     Reply RE: Wherein I blaspheme!, Isildur, 15-Sep-06 01:33 PM, #8
          Reply RE: Wherein I blaspheme!, nepenthe, 15-Sep-06 06:10 PM, #12
               Reply RE: Wherein I blaspheme!, Isildur, 15-Sep-06 07:06 PM, #14
               Reply If you valued Ulzammon at all, you will read the last b..., TheLastMohican, 15-Sep-06 07:29 PM, #15
Reply Three Cheers for George R.R. Martin!, wretchedmongrel, 14-Sep-06 11:48 PM, #1
Top Non-CF Discussion "What Does RL Stand For?" Topic #364 Previous topic | Next topic