Subject: "RE: Until I was 27..." Previous topic | Next topic
Printer-friendly copy Email this topic to a friend CF Website
Top Non-CF Discussion "What Does RL Stand For?" Topic #234
Show all folders

AmarantheFri 27-Oct-06 04:27 PM
Member since 17th Mar 2003
536 posts
Click to send email to this author Click to send private message to this author Click to view this author's profile Click to add this author to your buddy list
#654, "RE: Until I was 27..."
Edited on Fri 27-Oct-06 04:33 PM

          


Aikido is a woman's art for the reasons you said.


Do you mean to say Aikido isn't for men?

If so, what would you say to men like Ueshiba Morihei, Mitsugi Saotome, Donovan Waite, and other very strong and martial men who have practiced or practice Aikido?

Even here in diverse California, the dojo where I train, which has been around 20 years, tested its first woman for shodan only 2 years ago.

Aikido does appeal to women more than other martial arts, and I'd say the fact that it appeals to women and men, mostly adults, makes it a strong and balanced martial art, not a "woman's art". Before I found Aikido, I admit I walked into a Tae Kwon Do dojo with an interest towards training. The throng of 12-year-old boys trying to earn their "camo belt" (I am *not* making that up!) had me out of there within 5 minutes.

The reason there is no competition in true Aikido isn't because the Aikido philosophy doesn't believe in competition, but because Aikido techniques (and in fact many martial arts techniques) are potentially so damaging that it is extremely dangerous to practice with anything short of compassion, blending, and restraint, which a "I must win" mentality conflicts with. A friend of mine just had surgery to re-attach his bicep that was torn away from his bone because someone doing a demonstration with him as uke decided, after opening his own dojo, that it was necessary to show his new students what "real Aikido" was. This man is a shodan, a body builder, and has *excellent* ukemi. The reason he was injured as badly as he was wasn't a lack of skill from either partner, but rather an overabundance of testosterone and pride. (Which he'll readily admit himself at this point.)

The women I know who train in Aikido are often constantly training to try to become more assertive and more martial, and the men more compassionate and peace-oriented. When someone truly gets that balance, it's a strong and beautiful thing.

Ultimately one doesn't train in Aikido because they want to kick ass in real-life situations, but I've never heard of a serious Aikido practicioner who had the art fail them if and when such an eventuality occurred. There's no fisticuffs though... just one technique and it's done.

Not trying to sell you on Aikido, but if you were training in any martial art and getting into fights every weekend, I wonder if you might consider embracing the whole discpline/budo aspect of martial arts training.

  

Alert | IP Printer Friendly copy | Reply | Reply with quote

HOT TopicNew topic: Any martial arts people out there? [View all] , Barduin, Thu 07-Sep-06 04:33 PM
Reply Capoeira, Aikido, Tai Chi, Muuloc, 24-Nov-06 07:53 PM, #27
Reply RE: New topic: Any martial arts people out there?, KirkBurner, 09-Nov-06 08:49 AM, #26
Reply I think that the biggest benifits of any martial art ar..., (NOT Pro), 23-Oct-06 07:54 PM, #20
Reply RE: I think that the biggest benifits of any martial ar..., Amaranthe, 25-Oct-06 09:45 PM, #21
     Reply Until I was 27..., (NOT Pro), 26-Oct-06 07:03 PM, #22
          Reply Experience is the greatest teacher of anything, Stunna, 27-Oct-06 03:16 PM, #23
          Reply RE: Until I was 27..., Amaranthe, 27-Oct-06 04:33 PM #24
               Reply What I should have said..., (NOT Pro), 28-Oct-06 01:48 PM, #25
Reply Brazilian Jiu Jitsu, Undead_Irish, 24-Sep-06 11:11 PM, #19
Reply Anyone know of Combat JKD or Chris Clugston?, Theerkla, 19-Sep-06 08:52 AM, #16
Reply What I know of JKD, Valkenar, 21-Sep-06 11:16 AM, #18
Reply A while back we had a related discussion on QHCF, Quixotic, 09-Sep-06 08:54 PM, #11
Reply I want to see the video!, Stunna, 20-Sep-06 06:24 PM, #17
Reply Complex Question, Ysaloerye, 09-Sep-06 03:59 PM, #10
Reply Read this:, Stunna, 11-Sep-06 07:01 AM, #13
     Reply Yep that guy has got it, Ysaloerye, 17-Sep-06 08:33 PM, #14
          Reply I AM the guy who wrote it! ;) n/t, Stunna, 19-Sep-06 08:33 AM, #15
Reply I own two schools., Stunna, 09-Sep-06 08:57 AM, #7
Reply RE: New topic: Any martial arts people out there?, N b M, 08-Sep-06 08:46 PM, #6
Reply The Gentle Way..., Lightmage, 08-Sep-06 08:03 PM, #5
Reply Not an olympic sport, actually, Stunna, 09-Sep-06 09:00 AM, #8
     Reply Wrong, DurNominator, 09-Sep-06 10:03 AM, #9
          Reply I stand corrected..., Stunna, 11-Sep-06 06:57 AM, #12
Reply Yoshukai and Kenpo when I was younger, Rogue, 08-Sep-06 07:20 PM, #4
Reply RE: New topic: Any martial arts people out there?, Valkenar, 08-Sep-06 07:17 PM, #3
Reply Aikido, Amaranthe, 08-Sep-06 02:28 PM, #1
     Reply Gazoontite...nt, Saith, 08-Sep-06 07:13 PM, #2
Top Non-CF Discussion "What Does RL Stand For?" Topic #234 Previous topic | Next topic