This is mostly because of that argument at the Village. Though it
was apparent that you were taking the side of the 'honorably fight
the mages you fight', you made it seem like that was just your
opinion, rather than telling us that's what we're supposed to do.
I had thought you were taking the safe route by not saying the
wrong thing as Captain, and that you shoulda just chose one way
to handle it and thats that. Took awhile to drag the answer out
of you, you started off talking about someone trashing Rhuean's
character (as in personality, not player).

At least that's why I thought it. On the other spectrum, Shamus
is more the one to call you a bloody idiot if you're doing something
wrong. Its a little more proactive and commanding way to lead.