If you're going to do this, then do it right. Add up the accumulated hit/dam/saves/hp/mana/str.. whatever for your set.

And then compare it to an evil set.

What you posted is completely worthless except to demonstrate that you haven't thought this comparison through. At least, not beyond "Goodies have it easy because Heartseekers are in the game and they can request crap gear."

For extra fun, exclude armor that has a red aura (for goodies without access to Paladins).