No they aren't. 95% of the players take an ultra-conservative view of it because they're afraid that the interpretation of the rules may be stricter or more lax depending on the imm involved.

That's not clearly defined, that's vaguely defined combined with people who are afraid to cross a boundary that they don't know where it ends at.

If it makes you feel better, ignore Torak's posts and just look at mine. I'm not Torak, I haven't ever had a character denied, I've never been accused of cheating, I'm just an honest guy trying to figure out what I'm allowed to do and not allowed to do.