Outlander has no applicant status, your metaphor fails.

But I think you're right, it only makes sense that someone who is considered "in the cabal" by zulg to not be able to have access to the cabals philosophy. It only makes sense for someone "in the cabal" to have no direct access to the cabals rules. Seriously.
This is now a thread about petitioning the removal of this information for squires, scribes, and bloodoaths.

THESE PEOPLE ARE JUST "IN THE CABAL" ACCORDING TO ZULG. WHY THEY DESERVE ACCESS TO THE CABALS RULES IF THEYRE JUST "IN THE CABAL"? IF YOU'RE "IN THE CABAL", YOU SHOULDN'T BE SPOON FED THINGS LIKE BASIC RULES. YOU'RE JUST "IN THE CABAL" ACCORDING TO ZULG. YOU'RE NOT BORN WITH KNOWING THE BASIC RULES, AND AS A OATH, SCRIBE, ACOLYTE, AND VILLAGE APPLICANT YOU ARE ONLY IN THE CABAL. VILLAGE APPLICANTS CERTAINLY DONT DESERVE IT.

We need to remove the access to the information that scribes, squires, and bloodoaths have. It would be a learning process oath attacking in a city, or a acolyte breaking whatever their rules are, and get uninducted.
It's not fair to the squires, scribes, and bloodoaths that THEY get this information. Giving them this information ruins the learning experience.

It should take a newbie 150 extra hours to redeem themselves or a new character to get it right, once they #### up by breaking the MOST BASIC of their cabals rules and get smacked down.

Just like how great a learning experience it would be if bloodoaths couldn't read laws, or if scribes couldn't read their restrictions and got uninducted just for the sake of the basic information ON THE MOST BASIC REQUIREMENTS OF HOW TO ACT IN THE CABAL are not listed for them.

I agree, they can make a 2nd char if they want to get in, once their first gets uninducted/blacklisted and then they know what not to do.