>If you're taking this, you're already sacrificing the
>ability to get the instrument edges and use some cool
>instruments....be nice to be able to have vocal ability
>comparable to an instrument, even if the edge needs to be
>expensive.
>
>The ability to swap a shield in for an instrument without
>penalty would be incredibly powerful, and likely beyond the
>scope of any Edge. The existing Edge makes the tradeoff
>slightly less painful, which is still plenty good, but keeps a
>strategic choice in play.
>
>valguarnera@carrionfields.com

You still have a lose from not using tune and the instrument edges.