Personally, I hate the idea of edge points being earned via imm experience. I would hope other people might share my view somewhat, but here's why it is the way it is. Humans are not infallible... we have opinions, we're subject to being bias on occasion. That said, I could easily picture a character that has a great role/description and just possibly rub an immortal the wrong way. This might seem rare, but what about the flip side where a mortal has a great role and gets what could be viewed too much attention?

Now if guidelines have been put in place for awarding xp, maybe this is all irrelevant. However, I would be much more obliged for a purely player-driven system. (ie, pk stats, commerce xp, observation xp, etc)

I also would not be opposed to edge points being earned on imm xp staples such as when you get inducted to a cabal, promotion within cabals, empowerment, quest completions.

Also, as possibly an idea: Can edge points be earned for level gains? (the least possible amount) It would simply serve for at least a guarantee to pick at least an edge by say level 30 or however it was worked out mathematically.

Anyhow, does anybody agree with this? Or am I just staying up too late to think properly?

Shadow1ife