The pray-er in question seems to be convinced that if:
1) ... anyone kills him, they're obviously an Immortal.
2) ... if his alignment gets changed, it was obviously because someone he killed was an Immortal, and not because of crappy paper-thin roleplay.

As for Talnic, I'm no PK genius, but I also don't remember having to ask what this strange Sleep spell was good for. :P I was trying to get you to pause before entering the area, since he was with a group of 2. Wanted you make sure you knew I was going to try and land the sleep, and the worry was the transmuter with him either waking the sleeper, or attacking us and waking the sleeper via your elemental's area spell. Fortunately, one of us thought of talking the groupmate into walking away quietly, and being able to walk away. :) For various role reasons, I killed 0 non-Sylvan magi (outside of Tower defense) in my mortal days, and didn't want to start there.