I understand your point. I just think it's too black and white. Good villagers have to walk a very fine line to balance morals with cabal interest.

Fail the moral side, and now you're neutral.
Fail the cabal side, and now you're uninducted.

Where that line is drawn, and how it is applied to each character who tries to walk it, and how his cabalmates react to it, is what makes the role interesting.

Besides, the shift to a more Students of War style back in uh... 2001 or something provides a good out for this style. Know your enemy and all that jazz.

I'm just throwing my opinion out there. Having played a successful good-aligned rager in the past, I thought it might be a worthwhile contribution.