>I always found Fhaen to be roleplaying, and that pbf
>comment didn't mention a lack of roleplaying.

You definitely saw a different Fhaen than I did. I waffled on docking him a handful of XP a number of times for comments that seemed fairly OOC to me. Ultimately I decided not to, so whatever it was probably wasn't all that awful.

Just saying, it's not necessarily obvious from his RP or in-game interaction what he was trying to do there. I certainly saw hours of Fhaen and I couldn't even begin to take a guess. From what you're saying it sounds like there was something there, but that just makes this even more the textbook case where even a one-paragraph quickie role could have helped someone watching him understand what he was getting at SO much.