Look at it this way, when you join ragers after a while you know certain items are a no no, it aint written specifically anywhere in the village that those items are BAAAAD items, but everyone knows and its a consensus.

I have had about erm...., seven or eight tribunals, counting some arbiters in there. That is just the way it has been for quite a while.

And about the off-duty investigation, that is something I was told IC by Marmaanth and I tried to enforce it as best I could. It was something new and I wanted for everyone to abbide by it.
Again, it aint written anywhere in the spire,but thats how it is. And of course there isnt a black and white case even less that of the nightgaunts so I had to "judge" as best I could.

Good luck to you too