Then tell me how many characters rolled around that same time are still kicking. Admittedly I'm not what you'd call a casual player, but plenty of people who are still put in ####loads more time than Kelin did. Also, the infrequent logins were only a small part of my beef. One or the other taken alone wouldn't really be grounds so much for a complaint (the being off and unavailable more than the other) but together, it shows a pattern of choosing both his logins and his availability when logged in, based on how difficult his opposition was.