And I gave you enough examples to show how such treatment of law 3 leads to nonsensical and obviously unjust consequences.

If you allow flagging for assisting outside the city, then in almost any situation you can find a justification to flag someone who attacks you. Hell, you can flag anyone who kills an Udgaard sentry.

You are just looking for excuses to use your powers on people who never had any intent of running afoul of the law. This is the worst thing a Trib can do, short of just flagging everyone on who list.