Is that we are back to role exp farming. Which actually doesn't mean a character is well rp'd. Hence we are back to giving rewards for an ooc behaviour which may or may not be translating into the ic behaviours desired. Rewarding with pk perks for storytelling rather than being a character.

One beauty of the system as it was is that the blurring between role play and just writing about roles was less significant in terms if the potential pk perks it yielded.

All that said (and noting I can't play these days), I'd still rather see edge points available from a system I'm not keen on than not available at all. Because whilst role exp gets farmed, it is at least somewhat balanced.